NEWS AND INSIGHT

The Shareholder's Right to Information and the Balance Between the Personal Data Protection Law and Trade Secrets


13 August 2025 - Tevetoğlu Legal

The Shareholder's Right to Information and the Balance Between the Personal Data Protection Law and Trade Secrets

The decision of the Istanbul 14th Civil Commercial Court dated June 26, 2025, numbered E. 2024/501, K. 2025/517, contains important findings on how to establish a balance between the right of company shareholders to obtain information and conduct inspections and the concepts of personal data protection and trade secrets.

 

In the case in question, a minority shareholder filed a lawsuit alleging that their right to information under Article 437 of the Turkish Commercial Code had been violated. The information requested included: (i) the company's financial data, (ii) payments made to managers, (iii) travel and representation expenses, (iv) KVKK compliance documents, and (v) future investment plans. The defendant company argued that some of the requests were commercial secrets and that the plaintiff was engaged in activities at a competing company.

 

The court's decision summarized the following points:

 

The right to information is a fundamental right granted to shareholders to enable them to monitor the company's operations and exercise their shareholder rights in an informed manner. This right has been evaluated within the scope of the property right guaranteed by the Constitution.

Pursuant to KVKK Article 5/2-(f), personal data processing activities necessary for “the establishment, exercise, or protection of a right” are lawful. Providing the information necessary for the exercise of shareholder rights also constitutes a legitimate reason for data processing.

The protection of personal data cannot be completely disregarded; the principle of data minimization must be observed, and anonymized or position-based information should be shared whenever possible.

Limiting information requests to the last three years for the purpose of protecting the company's interests was deemed reasonable.

Considering that the plaintiff works for a competing company, information that truly constitutes trade secrets and cannot be disclosed even through anonymization was excluded from the scope.

Information requests regarding the company's compliance with the KVKK have been deemed lawful in accordance with the principle of transparency.

The relevant decision provides guidance for companies to adopt a balanced approach when evaluating information requests, while protecting the KVKK and commercial secret sensitivities.

 

The full text of the relevant decision is provided below.