A NEW CHALLENGE FOR SPORTS LAW: TOKENIZATION OF ATHLETES !
I. Introduction
In today's world of rapidly developing digitalization, blockchain technology is radically transforming the sports industry, as it has done in many other areas such as finance, art and entertainment. This transformation is based on tokenizing digital assets and securing them with blockchain infrastructure. This structure enables clubs, fans and athletes to create new revenue models.
The most striking dimension of this transformation in the context of sports law is the tokenization of the personal rights and values of individual athletes - primarily image rights, sponsorship revenues and performance expectations - into investment instruments. This phenomenon, called "tokenization of athletes", has multi-layered consequences on both legal, economic and ethical levels.
Within the scope of this article; the concept of tokenization of athletes is defined, its applications in Turkey and in the world are discussed with examples, evaluations are made within the framework of the current legal system and the risks, needs and solution proposals arising especially in terms of Turkish sports law are explained.
II. So What is Tokenization?
Tokenization is the process of converting a tangible or intangible asset into a digital representation using blockchain technology. These digital representations are called "tokens" and are legally classified as securities ("security tokens"), utility tokens ("utility tokens") or hybrid tokens ("hybrid tokens").
In the sports sector, three main forms of tokenization come to the fore:
1) Fan Tokens: Issued by sports clubs and grant fans limited digital rights (voting, access to exclusive content, etc.).
2) Athlete Tokens: Individual athletes' image rights, sponsorship potential or career income prospects are tokenized and offered to investors. They can also be in NFT format.
3) Testimonial Tokenization: It can be formulated as the funding of the players' contracts by the fans, giving tokens to the fans in return for the funding, using the tokens in the first 11 and transfer voting, and giving a revenue share to the token holders who participated in the funding from the revenue generated from the next transfer.
III. Tokenization Practices of Athletes
At the beginning of their careers or in times of specific financial need, athletes prefer to tokenize a certain percentage of their future income and offer it to investors. This model is similar to the structures known as "Future Income Share Agreement" in the US.
Therefore, some athletes are turning their names, images or branded identity elements into digital collectibles in NFT format and releasing them in limited editions. These tokens have both investment value and collectability. NBA player Spencer Dinwiddie's tokenization of his contract revenues and offering them to investors is considered one of the pioneering examples of this field.
In other words, these structures provide financing to athletes at an early stage. At the same time, they promise investors a performance-indexed financial return linked to sporting success.
IV. Fan Token Applications in Turkey and Legal Developments within the Framework of the Cryptocurrency Ecosystem
Turkey has a very active ecosystem in the field of cryptocurrency and digital assets. Law No. 7518 and Law No. 6493 have largely shaped the legal infrastructure of crypto assets and electronic currencies. The Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey ("CBRT") does not consider crypto assets as electronic money. Fan tokens are not recognized as direct investment instruments by both the CBRT and the Capital Markets Board ("CMB").
The CMB has stated that token structures that have investment purposes and generate income expectations may be considered as securities and that such structures will be subject to authorization. As for the parties generating income, it is clear that token sales revenues are subject to declaration under the Income Tax Law.
In parallel with these developments, Turkish sports clubs have also turned to fan token projects and realized important applications in this field. Especially football clubs have started to use these tools to compensate for economic losses in the post-pandemic period and to establish closer digital ties with fans.
In this context, the prominent club applications in the field of fan token in Turkey are as follows:
- Galatasaray: Galatasaray was the first club in Turkey to issue a fan token (GAL) on the Socios.com platform. At the same time, it made a global impact in the field of NFTs by issuing the "Ali Sami Yen NFT" collection.
- Fenerbahçe: launched FB Token on a local platform. The project achieved a great pre-sale success.
- Trabzonspor & Beşiktaş: Tokens issued through Socios were used to offer rights such as fan surveys, access to exclusive content and VIP event participation.
- Bursaspor, Karşıyaka: Anatolian clubs that entered the fan token world through Bitci Technology have also discovered the potential of this system.
Related fan token applications have become an important part of digitalization strategies. They are also undoubtedly an alternative financing tool for clubs.
V. How should the legal and financial dimension be shaped within this framework?
i) Personality and Image Rights: According to the Turkish Civil Code and the Turkish Code of Obligations, personality rights cannot be transferred without consent and cannot be transferred to third parties. The digitization of these rights in athlete tokens should be secured by explicit consent and contractual arrangements.
ii) Contractual Arrangements: In professional contracts between athletes and clubs, digital rights and token projects should be clearly defined. Otherwise, serious disputes will inevitably arise regarding rights ownership, revenue sharing and usage permissions.
iii) Tax Liabilities: Revenues arising from token sales must be declared under the Income Tax Law. In addition, tokens that have an investment character may be subject to CMB audit.
iv) International Regulations: Token projects must comply not only with national law but also with the regulations of international organizations such as UEFA, FIFA, FIBA.
VI. Legal and Financial Risks and Assessments Regarding Tokenization of Athletes
- Legal Uncertainty
Fan tokens and sports tokens are generally considered to be outside the scope of capital market law.
- Financial Manipulation Risk
Low liquidity on platforms where tokens are traded creates an open ground for price manipulation. This situation paves the way for manipulative actions such as investor misleading and "pump and dump".
- KVKK and GDPR Compliance
Within the scope of KVKK and GDPR, data processing processes must be carried out in accordance with the principles of explicit consent and data minimization.
- Technological Risks
Errors that may occur in smart contract codes put the digital assets of the investor and the athlete at risk. Therefore, audited and secure platforms should be preferred.
- Reputation Management
Failed or speculative token projects can damage the brand value of athletes and clubs. Reputation-protective digital communication strategies should therefore be adopted.
VII. Conclusion and Final Assessment
In line with the aforementioned explanations, it is seen that the tokenization processes of athletes and clubs are an innovative model that both supports financial sustainability and strengthens digital branding processes within the contemporary sports industry.
However, the healthy functioning of this structure depends not only on technological solutions and developments, but also on the strengthening of the legal framework and the transparent implementation of best practices.
In this context;
- Athlete contracts should include clear provisions on the use of digital assets and image rights.
- Token projects should be analyzed in terms of CMB, UEFA, FIFA, FIBA regulations; in particular, it should be determined whether the investment-oriented structures are considered within the scope of capital market instruments.
- For NFTs and similar assets, copyrights linked to FSEK should be examined.
- Legal feasibility and tax analysis should be conducted before token projects are implemented.