A Review on the Doctrine of "Corporate Separation" in Trademark Disputes under the Lanham Trademark Act
Dewberry Engineers Inc. v. Dewberry Group Inc.
In Dewberry Engineers Inc. v. Dewberry Group Inc., the Supreme Court of the United States of America discussed the limits of the concept of "defendant's profits" in the calculation of damages for trademark infringement. In particular, the agenda of whether the courts can calculate damages by taking into account the profits of subsidiaries that are not parties to the lawsuit but operate under common ownership, and the possibility of increasing the financial liability of these subsidiaries in trademark disputes are emphasized.
In this article, we will examine the subject matter of the dispute underlying the possibility of this decision, the treatment of the case under the Lanham Act, and the doctrine of corporate separation.
- Lanham Trademark
The Lanham Trademark Act ("Lanham Act"), also known as the Trademark Act of 1946, is a U.S. federal ("U.S.") law that governs trademark law, including registration through the United States ("U.S.") Patent and Trademark Office ("USPTO"), maintenance, and protection of trademarks affecting or used in interstate commerce . [1]
The Lanham Act also provides for causes of action in national courts for various unfair competition claims, including trademark dilution, cybersquatting and unregistered trademark infringement (including infringement of unregistered trade dress and trade name marks), misleading advertising, false endorsement and false designation of origin.
By its very existence, the Lanham Act does not override the common law trademark and unfair competition principles of other states or state trademark laws.
- Dewberry Group, Inc. v. Dewberry Engineers Inc.
At issue in this case is whether, under 15 U.S.C. 1117(a), the defendant's profits may include the separate profits of legally separate and non-party corporate affiliates. 1117(a) entitles the owner of a registered trademark, on principles of equality, to disgorgement of ill-gotten gains from the profits of the infringer.
The controversial process initially began when Dewberry Group Inc. (then known as "Dewberry Capital") sent a cease and desist letter to Dewberry Engineers Inc. stating that "there is a likelihood of confusion or association between the parties' respective marks". Although Dewberry Engineers Inc. stated that "Dewberry" was a national trademark of theirs, Dewberry Group Inc. argued that they used "Dewberry" in connection with real estate development and related services and therefore had priority common law rights.
When Dewberry Engineers Inc. brought an action for trademark infringement against Dewberry Group Inc. alleging that the marks were confusingly similar, Dewberry Engineers Inc. claimed that Dewberry Group Inc.'s use of the "Dewberry" mark would harm its companies' trademark rights because both parties to the action associated their marks with real estate development services.
Dewberry Group Inc filed a counterclaim stating that Dewberry Engineers Inc's marks are "substantially similar to Dewberry Capital's "DEWBERRY CAPITAL" mark" and that when used in connection with real estate development services, they create a likelihood of confusion and association between the marks and a risk of mistake and confusion[2] . In fact, the USPTO rejected the registration application of "Dewberry Capital" on the grounds that there was a strong likelihood of confusion between "Dewberry" and "Dewberry Capital".
In 2007, about a year after the lawsuit was filed, before the merits of the case had been reached, a confidential settlement process was conducted between the parties, which resulted in a number of restrictions on the Dewberry Group's use of the trademark.
However, when the Dewberry Group filed new trademark registration applications with the USPTO in 2017, Dewberry Engineers Inc. filed a lawsuit in 2020 alleging that certain marks that were part of the rebranding process violated the trademark use restriction subject to the confidential settlement between the parties.
With respect to Dewberry Engineers Inc.'s claims, Dewberry Group Inc. argued that, based on the plain text of the Lanham Act, only profits directly derived by the defendant corporation were recoverable. In this case, it argued that taking into account the profits of subsidiaries violates the principle of corporate separation and that the existence of separate legal entities should be preserved.
On the other hand, Dewberry Engineers Inc. argued that the Lanham Act has a two-stage calculation method, with net profits being determined in the first stage and the fair value provision coming into play in the second stage, allowing for the evaluation of additional evidence to determine actual economic gain.
The district court, in its decision dated August 11, 2021, first granted summary judgment in favor of Dewberry Engineers Inc. in the lawsuit filed by Dewberry Engineers Inc.[3] . After a three-day trial, the court ordered the Dewberry Group to disgorge approximately $43 million in profits realized by its subsidiaries, despite the fact that the Dewberry Group had declared a loss on its own tax records, to disgorge ill-gotten gains, to prevent breach of the parties' settlement, and to pay attorneys' fees and costs of the proceedings .[4]
In 2023, the Fourth Chamber of the Court of Appeal also upheld the decision of the District Court, emphasizing that the discretion of the courts may be exercised in accordance with "principles of equality". The Fourth Chamber of the Court of Appeal also held that the District Court had not abused its discretion in finding that the disgorgement of profits was appropriate, treating the defendant and its subsidiaries as a single corporate entity for the purposes of profit calculations. Although the subsidiaries were not named as defendants in this case, they were found to have received all revenues associated with the infringing activities.
Therefore, in this case, the scope of the principle of corporate separateness has been addressed in different aspects, together with the evaluations within the framework of the possibility of registered trademark owners to demand protection against unauthorized use of their trademarks and the refund of the unjust gains obtained as a result of the infringement pursuant to section 1117(a) of the Lanham Act.
- Corporate Separation Principle
The principle of corporate separation has been a shield protecting affiliated business entities such as subsidiaries, affiliates and parent companies from various liabilities and lawsuits.
The doctrine of corporate separateness underpins the way many businesses structure their operations. Indeed, reliance on the now historically established rule that companies are not liable for the acts or obligations of their subsidiaries "unless the corporate veil is pierced"[5] and companies often deliberately choose to create and operate through holding companies and/or one or more subsidiary corporate identities in order to reduce risk and protect certain assets from the reach of potential creditors. Thus, any infringement of the doctrine of corporate separateness would have significant consequences for many commercial actors.
At the trial stage of the case, this principle was defined as meaning that if the separate legal personality of a company is abused, under certain circumstances, to conceal the personal liability of the owners of the company, the courts should lift this veil. In Virginia, it has been held that the principle of corporate separateness requires the court to take into account "the specific factual circumstances of the corporation and the acts in question".
For example, in O'Hazza v. Executive Credit Corp. the court considered the initial capital, whether there was a breach of corporate formalities, whether the company was established for a legitimate purpose and whether there was an improper use of financial resources . [6]
Dewberry Group Inc. also argues in this case that subsidiaries are separate legal entities and, therefore, their profits should not be directly attributable to the profits of the subject company. This approach is based on the fundamental principle of the doctrine of corporate separateness, particularly supported by the decision in United States v. Bestfoods[7] . On the other hand, Dewberry Engineers Inc. argues that if the subsidiaries played the main role in the actual generation of economic profits, such profits may be attributed to the economic benefit of the defendant company, but this should be based on a careful assessment by the courts.
On December 11, 2024, during the oral arguments, most members of the court expressed concern about preserving institutional separation, while at the same time discussing the need to take economic reality into account.
It remains to be seen whether the discussion of the doctrine of corporate separation in Dewberry Engineers Inc. v. Dewberry Group Inc. will be an important turning point in the consideration of this case, and also whether the Supreme Court will overturn the lower courts' decisions or limit their scope.
On the one hand, it is possible that the Supreme Court may seek to reaffirm the scope of the courts' equitable powers, particularly in the face of the requirements of the Lanham Act, which gives courts a wide scope to award damages to prevent injustice. On the other hand, it is also possible that the Supreme Court may conclude this case on the basis of its tendency to overturn the decisions of the lower courts, thereby reinforcing the principle of institutional separation.
- Conclusion
As a result of the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals' affirmance of the District Court's decision, we find that Dewberry Engineers' request for "careful scrutiny" evaluated all of the substantive elements of the Lanham Act's two-step calculation method.
The Supreme Court's decision in this case may affect the application of the doctrine of corporate separateness, the idea that corporations are not liable for the acts or obligations of their subsidiaries, and may test the limits of the equitable powers of lower courts to order disgorgement of ill-gotten gains by non-party corporate affiliates.
Moreover, the jurisdictional debate will undoubtedly extend beyond trademark law, as there are other laws that give courts equitable discretion to fashion a similar remedy. Therefore, the Supreme Court's highly anticipated final judgment will have an impact on the business world, especially with implications beyond trademark law.
Will the Supreme Court's final decision breathe new life into the established practice on the principle of corporate separateness? Or will the case be sent back to the lower courts for reconsideration? Although the case has not yet been concluded, it is possible to say that the decision to be rendered will have significant effects not only in the field of trademark law, but also in many other areas such as copyright, patent, trade secrets and financial law. Therefore, it will be inevitable to focus on the effects of this case in different areas of law in the future.
[1] 15 U.S.C. §§ 1051 to 1127.
[2] J.A. 2463-64
[3] Dewberry Engineers, 2021 WL 5217016
[4] Dewberry Engineers, Inc. v. Dewberry Grp., Inc., No. 1:20-CV-00610, 2021 WL 5217016, at *1 (E.D. Va. Aug. 11, 2021), aff'd, 77 F.4th 265 (4th Cir. 2023), cert. granted, 144 S.Ct. 2681 (2024).
[5] Bestfoods, 524 USA, 61-62.
[6] O'Hazza v. Executive Credit Corp. 111, 431 S.E.2d 318, 321 (1993)
[7] United States v. Bestfoods , 524 US 51, 61 (1998).