OUR PUBLICATIONS

An Analysis of the Turkish Grand National Assembly's Digital Copyright Bill


20 December 2025 - Av. Beyza Can

An Analysis of the Turkish Grand National Assembly's Digital Copyright Bill

The rapid development of digital technologies and the global spread of communication infrastructures have qualitatively transformed the processes of production, reproduction, and circulation of intellectual and artistic works; this transformation has begun to seriously challenge the classical assumptions and established balances of copyright law. Traditional copyright regimes, built on the logic of reproduction based on physical carriers and limited distribution, are proving inadequate in the face of the borderless, instantaneous, and multi-use nature of digital media; the relationship between economic value and legal protection is becoming increasingly problematic, particularly with regard to news content. This situation not only leads to the infringement of the financial rights of authors and journalists, but also creates structural risks in terms of the sustainability of public information production.

The Digital Copyright Bill[1] ("Bill") prepared in this context aims to systematically re-examine the scattered and inadequate regulations in Turkey to date regarding the protection of intellectual and artistic works and news content shared in digital environments under copyright law. While preserving the fundamental principles of the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, the Bill aims to establish a normative bridge between classical copyright law and contemporary digital practices by introducing specific provisions targeting issues specific to digital forms of use. In this respect, the proposal adopts an evolutionary approach that aims to adapt the existing legal structure to digital realities rather than radically changing it.

At the heart of the proposal is a clear normative preference that the financial and moral rights of authors must be fully protected in the digital environment. The proposal clearly defines the unauthorized copying, distribution, communication to the public, or adaptation of a work in digital media as copyright infringement, leaving no room for debate that digital use also constitutes "use" in the classical sense. This regulation plays an important role in eliminating the perception, commonly observed on the internet and lacking legal basis, that "accessible content can be used freely." At the same time, it aims to strengthen the rights of authors to seek re s and to make rights that have become unenforceable due to technical impossibilities operational again.

One of the most critical and controversial aspects of the proposal is the special licensing regime envisaged for news content. The systematic use of news texts, articles, and visual content by digital platforms and search engines, but with the economic benefits of this use largely concentrated in favor of the platforms, has long been one of the fundamental issues in copyright law at both the national and international levels. The proposal addresses this structural problem by linking the use of news content by digital platforms to licensing agreements, thereby aiming to redistribute economic value.

In this context, the requirement that at least thirty percent of the revenue generated from licensing agreements be distributed to reporters, writers, and photo-video journalists as royalties represents a noteworthy innovation in terms of recognizing labor at the individual level in copyright law. This regulation reflects an approach that balances the institutional rights of press organizations with the individual creative contributions of journalists. However, the fact that this percentage is set as a minimum threshold and can be increased through collective agreements shows that the norm aims to establish a minimum standard of fairness rather than imposing a rigid revenue sharing requirement.

On the other hand, while strengthening copyright protection, the proposal does not adopt an approach that could completely paralyze the functioning of the digital public sphere. The inclusion of short quotations and news headlines as exceptions, provided that they link to the relevant content and do not harm the legitimate interests of the author, is important in terms of freedom of expression and the public's right to information. This exception can be seen as a balancing mechanism aimed at limiting the potential negative effects of the absolutization of copyright on the digital public sphere.

The definition of "very large online platform" included in the proposal and the differentiated obligations envisaged accordingly are noteworthy in terms of reflecting the principle of proportionality in digital copyright law. Subjecting platforms with ten million unique monthly users in Turkey to heavier obligations aims to establish a proportional relationship between market power and legal liability. The requirement for these platforms to establish automatic content recognition systems, operate notification and content removal mechanisms, and submit transparency reports creates an institutional framework for the systematic prevention of copyright infringements. However, the proposal specifically emphasizes that these systems should not become a general oversight obligation, seeking to limit potential drawbacks in terms of freedom of expression and user rights.

The phased compliance process and technical support mechanisms envisaged for small and medium-sized platforms aim to prevent copyright law from stifling innovation in the digital economy. This approach demonstrates that copyright law is designed not only to protect rights holders but also to foster digital entrepreneurship and competition.

The provisions of the proposal relating to artificial intelligence technologies reveal that digital copyright law also takes into account future problem areas. The anticipation of authorship and infringement control in content generated by artificial intelligence or created through the reuse of copyrighted works constitutes an intervention in the legal uncertainties caused by systems trained on data sets. Subjecting companies that derive economic value from this content to revenue sharing obligations reflects the normative preference that copyright law should not only be protective but also perform a redistributive function.

The proposed establishment of a Copyright Monitoring Agency and a Board of Directors is seen as an administrative solution aimed at enhancing the effectiveness of digital copyright law. Monitoring copyright infringements and resolving licensing disputes through an institution with administrative and financial autonomy has the potential to reduce the burden on the courts. However, the independence of this structure and its ability to maintain an approach that respects freedom of expression in its decision-making processes will be decisive for the success of the proposal in practice.

While regulations on administrative fines offer a powerful tool for deterring copyright infringements, the proposal does not appear to absolutize its punitive logic. The fact that criteria such as the nature and duration of the infringement and the platform's good faith will be considered in determining penalties demonstrates that the principle of proportionality has been adopted at the normative level. Furthermore, the inclusion of incentive mechanisms alongside sanctions reveals that digital copyright law is designed not only to focus on sanctions but also to encourage compliance.

Ultimately, the Digital Copyright Bill claims to provide a comprehensive and systematic legal response to the long-standing structural problems related to the digital content ecosystem in Turkey. The Bill seeks to strike a delicate balance between strengthening copyright and freedom of expression and the public interest ; it aims to achieve this balance through institutional structures, licensing mechanisms, and the principle of proportionality. The success of the law will largely depend on how secondary legislation is drafted and the extent to which the judiciary and administrative bodies can preserve this balance in practice. In this respect, the proposal should be seen not only as a copyright regulation but also as an attempt to redefine the legal boundaries of the digital public sphere.