OUR PUBLICATIONS

Can Payments be Made with Cryptocurrency?


23 September 2023 - Av. Doç. Dr. Mete Tevetoğlu

Can Payments be Made with Cryptocurrency?

Av. Assoc. Prof. Dr. Mete Tevetoğlu

A payment is a legal transaction. It can be described as one of the types of transactions that terminate debt. The term payment appears in many places in our legislation. For example, the term payment is used 87 times in the Turkish Civil Code, which consists of 1030 articles, 185 times in the Turkish Code of Obligations, which consists of 649 articles, and 401 times in the Turkish Commercial Code, which consists of 1535 articles. However, somehow, none of them include an actual definition of a "payment".

Articles 99 and 100 of the Turkish Code of Obligations are noteworthy at this point...

Article 99 of the TCO is titled "Payment", however the article does not explain what payment is, but how it is made. According to the article, the debt, the subject matter of which is money, shall be paid in national currency. The opposite meaning suggests that a non-monetary debt may be paid in the national currency or in a currency other than the national currency. Further in the article, it is stated, that if it is agreed to be paid in a currency other than the national currency, the debt may also be paid in the national currency at the market price on the day of payment, unless the contract includes payment in kind or a statement to that effect. This sentence is for foreign currency debts. Again, there is no definition of payment. Continuing on, there is a provision stating that if the debt is determined in a currency other than the national currency and the contract does not include payment in kind or a statement to that effect, the creditor may demand payment of this receivable in kind or in national currency at the market price on the maturity or actual payment day, which is about how to make payment for foreign currency debts.

Article 100 of the TCO is titled "deduction". According to this, "if the debtor is not in arrears in the payment of interest or expenses, he has the right to deduct the partial payment from the principal debt. No agreement to the contrary may be made. If the creditor has obtained a surety, pledge or other security for part of the receivable, the debtor is not entitled to set off the partial payment against the secured or better secured part." We are searching, but it is not possible to find an answer to the question of what a payment is.

Article 139 of the TCO is noteworthy here as well. The article is about exchange. If two persons mutually owe each other a sum of money or other identical performance, each person may exchange their receivable for their debt, if both debts are due. In other words, money can be exchanged for money and non-money goods for goods of the same goods of their kind. However, this is not a payment. Meaning a payment, can terminate the debt, but a form of exchange in this sense is essentially different from a payment.

When we look at the issue in terms of the Law No. 6493 on Payment and Securities Settlement Systems, Payment Services and Electronic Money Institutions, we see that the term payment is mentioned 202 times in the Law. However, a definition of the term "payment" in this Law isn’t provided either.

Article 3 of Law No. 6493 defines a payment instrument as a personalized instrument such as a card, mobile phone, password or similar personalized instrument that is determined between the payment service provider and the payment service user and used by the payment service user to place a payment order. The payment order is understood as an instruction given by the payment service user to the payment service provider to execute the payment transaction. The Law defines a payment account as an account opened in the name of the payment service user and used for the execution of the payment transaction. The Law points out the payment service one by one with a long list of examples that can be seen below:

  1. All transactions necessary for the operation of the payment account, including services enabling the deposit and withdrawal of funds from the payment account,
  2. A direct debit transaction, including a one-off one, involving the transfer of funds from the payment account of the payment service user with the payment service provider, a payment transaction by payment card or similar instrument, and a transfer of money, including a standing order,
  3. Issuance or acceptance of the payment instrument,
  4. Money transfer
  5. A payment transaction where the sender gives consent for the payment to be made by means of an IT or electronic communication device and the payment is made to an IT or electronic communication operator that acts only as an intermediary between the payment service user and the provider of goods or services,
  6. Service for intermediation of bill payments,
  7. Payment order initiation service offered at the request of the payment service user in relation to a payment account at another payment service provider,
  8. The service of making available on online platforms consolidated information on one or more payment accounts of the payment service user with payment service providers, provided that the consent of the payment service user has been obtained,
  9. Other transactions and services that reach the status to be determined by the Bank in terms of total size or sphere of influence in the field of payments are payment services,

Yet still, this does not answer the question of what a payment is defined as.

Article 3 of the Law defines the closest payment transaction to the question of what a payment is: "the activity of depositing, transferring or withdrawing funds upon the instruction of the sender or recipient". The magic word here is fund. Funds are defined as banknotes, coins, dematerialized money, or electronic money in Article 3 of the same Law. Therefore, only these can be funds. Meaning, only their deposit, transfer and withdrawal are payment transactions. Therefore, according to the Law, depositing, transferring or withdrawing anything other than banknotes, coins, dematerialized money or electronic money is not a payment transaction.

We have examined all of this in order to better understand the Regulation on the Non-Use of Crypto Assets in Payments, issued based on Law No. 6493. This Regulation defines its purpose as determining the procedures and principles regarding the non-use of crypto assets in payments, the non-use of crypto assets directly or indirectly in the provision of payment services and the issuance of electronic money, and the non-intermediation of payment and electronic money institutions to platforms that provide trading, custody, transfer or issuance services related to crypto assets or fund transfers to be made from these platforms.

The Regulation is based on the subparagraph (f) and the fourth paragraph of the subparagraph (l) of the third paragraph of Article 4 of the Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey Law No. 1211 dated 14/1/1970 and the third paragraph of Article 12 and the sixth paragraph of Article 18 of the Law No. 6493 dated 20/6/2013 on Payment and Securities Settlement Systems, Payment Services and Electronic Money Institutions.

In summary, the Regulation prohibits the use of crypto assets in payments. Accordingly, in the application of the Regulation, crypto assets are defined as intangible assets that are created virtually using distributed ledger technology or a similar technology and distributed over digital networks, but are not characterized as fiat money, dematerialized money, electronic money, payment instruments, securities or other capital market instruments.

According to this regulation, crypto assets are not a "FUND" as defined in Law No. 6493. This is because the Law defines and limits a Fund as banknotes, coins, dematerialized money or electronic money. The Regulation, on the other hand, confirms that crypto assets are not FUNDS. According to the Law, payment transactions can only be made with FUNDS. Both the Law and the Regulation emphatically state that crypto assets are not FUNDS. Subsequently, while the Law defines Fund transfers as payment transactions and points out that cryptocurrency transfers are not payment transactions, the Regulation states that crypto assets cannot be used in payments, but not in payment transactions. At this point, it has led to a serious legal contradiction and error. According to the Regulation, crypto assets cannot be used directly or indirectly in payments.

The Turkish translation of the Regulation, which prohibits the indirect form of payment - although we do not even know what the direct form of a payment would be, can be understood as saying "it’s absolutely forbidden, brother". When we do not understand what is prohibited, it seems as if everything related to the subject is prohibited. This is a violation of the fundamental principle of proportionality in administrative restrictions. However, is the prohibition of use in payments and the prohibition of use in payment transactions the same thing? Or are they different? If it is the same, payment transactions are limited to funds and if crypto is not a fund, a crypto transfer cannot be considered as a payment and cannot be considered within the scope of the prohibition.

We are often asked what the penalty is if a transaction is considered to be in violation of this Regulation. There is no sanction or penalty in the Regulation. In accordance with the principle of legality in crime and punishment, crime and punishment can only be regulated by law. Unfortunately, at this point, we are faced with a Regulation that has no clear sanction. If the basic principle is legality in crime and punishment, there is no sanction for violating this Regulation. However, Article 27 of Law No. 6493 reads as follows: "Legal entities operating as system operators or payment service providers that violate the provisions of this Law and the regulations and decisions to be issued and taken based on this Law, and for which a separate criminal sanction is not stipulated in this Section, shall be imposed an administrative fine from forty thousand Turkish Liras to nine hundred thousand Turkish Liras by the Bank's Management Committee. However, in the event that benefit has been obtained or damage has been caused in this way, the amount of the administrative fine to be imposed cannot be less than twice the amount of this benefit or the damage caused.

In the event that one of these misdemeanors is committed more than once until an administrative sanction decision is issued, the person concerned shall be imposed an administrative fine and the fine to be imposed shall be doubled. However, in the event that a benefit is obtained or damage is caused by committing this misdemeanor, the amount of the administrative fine cannot be less than three times the amount of this benefit or damage." There is a tendency to apply the regulation as a sanction for violation of the Regulation. The phrase "who violates the provisions of this Law and the regulations and decisions to be issued based on this Law, and for which a separate criminal sanction is not stipulated in this Section" in this article means that the principle of legality in crime is pierced right through the middle. In other words, it is understood that even if there is no crime in the Law, violation of the Regulation can be subject to the penalty in the Law.

Unfortunately, this Regulation, which is faulty in all respects, contrary to the law-making technique and impossible to implement, has been in force for more than a year. The scope, subject matter and concept of the Regulation are unclear, and its sanctions are neither lawful nor foreseeable. What needs to be done is either to repeal this Regulation immediately or to replace it with a regulation that is in line with the current and fundamental principles of law within the scope of the general regulation on crypto assets. Let's see which of these two options time will bring us. Will the Regulation be repealed as we mentioned? Or will the issue be addressed in crypto regulation? Or will the Regulation be forgotten and remain in force in its incomplete and flawed form for years to come?