Changes in Banks' Remote Customer Acceptance
CHANGES IN BANKS' REMOTE CUSTOMER ACCEPTANCE (DIGITAL ONBOARDING) AND AN EVALUATION WITHIN THE SCOPE OF MASAK LEGISLATION
- INTRODUCTION
With the Regulation Amending the Regulation on Remote Identification Methods to be Used by Banks and Establishment of Contractual Relationship in Electronic Environment ("Regulation") published in the Official Gazette dated 25 May 2023 and numbered 32201 ("Amendment Regulation"), new regulations have been introduced regarding remote legal entity customer acceptance of banks regulated by the Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency ("BRSA").
With the additions made, commercial companies and real persons authorized to represent them are also included in remote customer acceptance. In addition, as we will discuss below, the Amendment Regulation also envisages changes regarding the needs of disabled customers and artificial intelligence applications. The common goal of all these regulations is to clarify and regulate the scope of banking practices and digital banking in all areas, which have become increasingly virtual after the global pandemic.
It should also be noted that the Amendment Regulation will enter into force on June 1, 2023 and will be implemented as of this date.
- REGULATION ON BANKS' ACCEPTANCE OF LEGAL ENTITY "CUSTOMERS"
- Scope of Regulation
The most important change introduced by the Amendment Regulation is that the term "Person", which defines real persons and real person merchants in the Regulation, has been revised as "Customer" with the inclusion of legal entities in the scope of the Regulation. With this amendment, banks will include the legal entity and the real person or persons authorized to represent them in the scope of remote identification.
The additions made to the Regulation after the Amended Regulation entered into force are as follows:
|
LEGAL ENTITIES INCLUDED IN THE SCOPE |
Collective, limited partnership, joint stock, limited liability and cooperative companies (Art. 3/1/n of the Regulation; Art. 124 of the TCC).
|
|
VERIFYING THE IDENTITY OF A LEGAL ENTITY |
It shall be confirmed whether the information obtained from the person regarding the legal entity matches the current information obtained by querying MERSIS, Trade Registry Gazette and the database of the Revenue Administration (Art. 7/B of the Regulation).
|
|
IDENTIFICATION OF THE REPRESENTATIVE
|
Identification is made in accordance with the Regulation and it is verified that the person is authorized to represent the legal entity. In case there is more than one person authorized to represent the legal entity, it is possible to perform this verification at different times.
If the person is already a customer of the same bank and the identity of the person is determined by logging in to any of the internet banking or mobile banking distribution channels regulated in the BSEBY[1], the requirements of the second and third paragraphs of Article 7 shall be deemed to have been fulfilled. (Art. 7/A/1 of the Regulation)
|
|
VERIFICATION OF AUTHORIZATION TO REPRESENT A LEGAL ENTITY |
The representative authority of the person is verified by matching the information obtained from the person with the up-to-date information obtained from MERSIS and/or the Trade Registry Gazette (Art. 7/A/2 of the Regulation).
If required by the Bank, the customer representative shall obtain a copy of the signature circular submitted by the person showing that the person is authorized to represent the legal entity. The signature sample obtained from the signature circular is compared with the signature sample in the identity document and/or MERSIS. Furthermore, the existence of the signature circular is confirmed by using the date and journal number on it (Art. 7/A/3 of the Regulation).
|
|
THE REAL BENEFICIARY AND ITS RECOGNITION
|
The real beneficiary is the real person who performs the transaction before the obligor, the real person on whose behalf the transaction is made, the real person or persons who ultimately control or have ultimate influence over legal entities or entities without legal personality (Art. 3/k of the Regulation; Art. 3/h of the Regulation on Measures to Prevent Laundering Proceeds of Crime and Financing of Terrorism published in the Official Gazette dated 9/1/2008 and numbered 26751).
During the process of identification of the legal entity; necessary measures are taken to reveal the real beneficiary of the legal entity (Art. 7/C of the Regulation).
|
- Assessment within the Scope of MASAK Legislation
As such, it is necessary to examine to what extent the said regulation regulates the remote customer acceptance of MASAK-obligated banks in parallel with the Regulation on Measures to Prevent Laundering Proceeds of Crime and Financing of Terrorism (hereinafter referred to as the "MASAK[2] Regulation") and the General Communiqué No. 19 of the Financial Crimes Investigation Board ("Communiqué No. 19") in terms of the documents required for identification and the verification methods of these documents. This is because remote customer acceptance is also within the scope of the obligation to recognize the customer, which is the third section of the MASAK Regulation, and the violation of this obligation is subject to administrative sanctions.
If we briefly touch upon the development of remote customer acceptance in MASAK legislation;
Within the scope of the MASAK Regulation, remote customer acceptance by banks for bank account opening and other transactions started with the introduction of a regulation, namely Article 6/A, which allows banks to accept customers primarily for natural persons. Communiqué No. 19 regulated the details of this acceptance mechanism.
The MASAK Regulation was amended[3] on April 5, 2023 to include legal entities in the scope of remote customer acceptance, and legal entities registered in the trade registry were added to Article 6/A, which allows remote identification. MASAK made an announcement on the same date ("MASAK Announcement") stating that legal entities registered in the trade registry are now allowed to accept customers through remote identification
"At the stage of technological developments and fintech applications, there has been a need to expand remote identification. In this context, "legal entities registered in the trade registry" has been added to Article 6/A of the Regulation on Measures to Prevent Laundering Proceeds of Crime and Financing of Terrorism, which allows remote identification between obligors and their customers. With this amendment, legal entities registered in the trade registry will also be able to perform many transactions such as opening accounts in banks, payment and electronic money institutions, intermediary institutions and other financial institutions through remote identification.[4]" it was added.
It can be understood from the reference to Communiqué No. 19, which will regulate the implementation principles, that the amendment to the MASAK Regulation is not sufficient on its own. It is stated that after this amendment, the details and implementation principles of remote identification for legal entities registered in the trade registry will be regulated separately in Communiqué No. 19.
As regards Communiqué No. 19, since no amendments have been made to it since 2021, the definition of "customer" in Communiqué No. 19 still covers only natural persons and natural person merchants of Turkish nationality.[5]Therefore, it is necessary to make an assessment between the definition of "customer" in the Regulation, which has been expanded by adding legal entities, and the definition of "customer" in Communiqué No. 19 in the MASAK legislation, which covers only real persons:
- In terms of the Hierarchy of Norms; If an evaluation is made in terms of the hierarchy of norms, the provisions of the communiqué at the lower level take their validity from the regulations at the upper level and therefore must comply with it. Here, both the MASAK Regulation and the Regulation have included the term legal entity within the scope of remote customer acceptance.
Even though the definition of "customer" is still not included in the scope of legal entities in Communiqué No. 19, Article 5 of Communiqué No. 19, which regulates remote identification in banking transactions, refers to the regulation to be regulated by the Regulation by stating that "Banks shall perform remote identification in establishing a continuous business relationship with their customers within the scope of the methods and measures specified in the Regulation on Remote Identification Methods to be Used by Banks and Establishment of Contractual Relationship in Electronic Environment published in the Official Gazette dated 1/4/2021 and numbered 31441." In this case, it can be inferred that the special regulations introduced by the Regulation regulate the scope of banks' acceptance of legal entity customers.
In light of the above, even if it is necessary to make an amendment to Communiqué No. 19 in order to eliminate doubts and as stated in the MASAK Announcement, it is considered that there will be no obstacle for banks to start accepting legal entity customers as of June 01, 2023, when the amendments in this Regulation will enter into force.
- OTHER CHANGES
The Amending Regulation has not only added commercial company legal entities to the scope of remote identification, but also envisaged some regulations in line with social needs and developing technology.
-
- Arrangements for the Needs of Persons with Disabilities
With the addition made to Article 4 of the Regulation, it is regulated that the remote identification process shall be designed in accordance with Article 4 of the Regulation on Accessibility of Banking Services published in the Official Gazette dated 18/6/2016 and numbered 29746 and that the controls specified in this regulation shall be established according to the disability status of persons with disabilities (Art. 4/9 of the Regulation).
In addition, it is stated that persons with disabilities may receive assistance from a third party during the video call phase of remote identification, if necessary, and that the customer representative will create photographs and/or screenshots showing the front and back sides of the third party who will provide assistance and his/her own identity document to be presented by this person (Art. 4/10 of the Regulation).
-
- Regulation of Artificial Intelligence Based Applications by the Board
Artificial intelligence was not forgotten in the Amendment Regulation, and by adding an additional article to the Regulation, the BRSA was authorized to determine the procedures and principles regarding the artificial intelligence-based applications and the transactions to be performed by artificial intelligence-based methods, which are stated to be performed by the customer representative in the Regulation (ANNEX ARTICLE 1 of the Regulation).
- CONCLUSION
Our conclusions from the regulations, which can be categorized under three main headings, are as follows:
- When these regulations are analyzed, it can be said that the disclosure of the acquisition of legal entity customers is an important development in terms of the integrity of the legislation on remote customer acceptance of banks. This regulation can also be said to bring an environmentalist approach to the sector in terms of sustainability as it will reduce the use of physical documents in banking services. In addition, as explained above, it is also a matter of curiosity when the definition of customer in Communiqué No. 19 will be updated.
- Clearly regulating the identity verification processes, which can sometimes be complex for real persons, by taking the measures that our disabled individuals may need and clearly regulating the facilities provided to them is important in terms of providing convenience for them to manage their financial transactions.
- Finally, the fact that the regulation of banking and digital banking applications, which is one of the sectors that use rapidly developing artificial intelligence applications most frequently, has been added to the wording of the legislation is an indication of this effect; leaving the issue to the authority of the BRSA without a written regulation is an indication that artificial intelligence applications in a rapidly developing sector cannot be regulated at once.
[1] 15/3/2020 tarihli ve 31069 sayılı Resmî Gazete’de yayımlanan Bankaların Bilgi Sistemleri ve Elektronik Bankacılık Hizmetleri Hakkında Yönetmeliği
[2] Mali Suçları Araştırma Kurulu
[3] 05 Nisan 2023 tarihli ve 32154 sayılı Resmî Gazete’de yayımlanan Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasının ve Terörün Finansmanının Önlenmesine Dair Tedbirler Hakkında Yönetmelikte Değişiklik Yapılmasına Dair Yönetmelik
[4] Bkz. https://masak.hmb.gov.tr/duyuru/suc-gelirlerinin-aklanmasinin-ve-terorun-finansmaninin-onlenmesine-dair-tedbirler-hakkinda-yonetmelikte-degisiklik-yapilmasina-dair-yonetmelik-05-nisan-2023-tarihli-ve-32154-sayili-resmi-gazete
[5] 19 No’lu Tebliğ, Madde 3/1/ç