CONSTITUTIONAL COURT RULING: STORAGE OF GENETIC DATA IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS
- INTRODUCTION
The Constitutional Court’s decision dated December 25, 2025, No. 2025/141 E., 2025/274 K.; published in the Official Gazette on March 18, 2026, the Constitutional Court annulled Article 80(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271 (“CMK”), which pertains to the storage of genetic data, as well as Article 82, which provides for the regulation of such procedures by decree.
This decision is significant not only for criminal procedure practice but also for Turkey’s data protection framework, as it reveals a structural normative gap regarding judicial data processing activities that fall outside the scope of the Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698 (“KVKK”). In particular, the processing, storage, and destruction of such data—which are classified as “special category personal data” under Article 6 of the KVKK and should therefore be subject to an enhanced protection regime—lacking a legal basis, and the extent to which this could raise issues regarding the right to the protection of personal data guaranteed under Article 20 of the Constitution and the principle of legality, formed the focal point of the Court’s review.
- REGULATIONS SUBJECT TO ANNULMENT
Pursuant to Article 80 of the Criminal Procedure Code, titled “Confidentiality of Genetic Examination Results”:
Paragraph (1) stipulates that the results of genetic testing constitute personal data, may not be used for any other purpose, and may not be disclosed to a third party.
Paragraph (2), on the other hand, provides that such data shall be destroyed only under specific circumstances:
“This information shall be immediately destroyed in the presence of the public prosecutor upon the expiration of the appeal period against a decision not to prosecute, the rejection of an appeal, or the finalization of a decision of acquittal or a decision that no penalty shall be imposed, and this fact shall be recorded in the minutes to be kept in the case file.”
On the other hand, Article 82 of the Criminal Procedure Code:
“The procedures for carrying out the operations provided for in Articles 75 through 81 are set forth in the regulation.”
Thus, it provides that the procedures and principles regarding the collection, examination, and, indirectly, the storage and destruction of genetic data shall be regulated by a regulation.
- MAIN GROUNDS FOR THE OBJECTION
In summary, the decision on the application states:
- Genetic data constitutes special-category personal data,
- Article 80/2 of the Criminal Procedure Code does not provide sufficient safeguards for the protection of such data,
- The regulation could potentially allow for the storage of data and the de facto creation of a DNA database beyond the listed cases,
- The fundamental aspects regarding the collection, storage, destruction, and access to such data are to be regulated by a regulation rather than by law,
- Therefore, it is argued that the rules are not specific or predictable and are open to arbitrariness
it has been argued that the regulation violates Articles 2, 13, 17, 20, and 40 of the Constitution.
- EXAMINATION OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK AND RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF THE LAW
Pursuant to the third paragraph of Article 20 of the Constitution:
“Everyone has the right to request the protection of personal data concerning them. This right includes the right to be informed about personal data concerning them, to access such data, to request their correction or deletion, and to learn whether they are being used for their intended purposes. Personal data may be processed only in cases provided by law or with the explicit consent of the individual. The principles and procedures regarding the protection of personal data are regulated by law.”
With this regulation, the right to the protection of personal data has been enshrined in the Constitution; it has been clearly established that any limitations on this right may only be imposed by law, in a specific and foreseeable manner.
On the other hand, Article 6 of the Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698 (KVKK) provides detailed regulations regarding special category personal data and the regime governing their processing:
“Data regarding a person’s race, ethnic origin, political views, philosophical beliefs, religion, denomination, or other beliefs, attire, membership in associations, foundations, or trade unions, health, sexual life, criminal convictions, and security measures, as well as biometric and genetic data, constitute special category personal data.”
The legislature has imposed stricter rules on the processing of special category personal data, which it has enumerated exhaustively, based on the significance of such data. The processing of special category personal data is prohibited except for the exceptions listed in paragraph 3 of Article 6 of the KVKK. The “Guidelines on Adequate Measures to Be Taken by Data Controllers in the Processing of Special Category Personal Data” issued by the Personal Data Protection Board also details the technical and administrative measures to be applied in the processing of such data. Pursuant to Article 6(3)(b) of the KVKK, which is among the aforementioned exceptions, the processing of special category personal data is permissible provided it is explicitly provided for by law; however, for this provision to apply, the relevant legal provision must be specific, accessible, and foreseeable.
Furthermore, pursuant to Article 28(1)(d) of the KVKK, titled “Exceptions”:
“The processing of personal data by judicial authorities or enforcement authorities in connection with investigative, prosecutorial, judicial, or enforcement proceedings”
is excluded from the scope of the law.
This provision results in the safeguards provided for in the KVKK (such as the duty to inform, the data subject’s rights to make requests, and conditions for data processing) not being directly applicable to personal data obtained and processed during criminal proceedings. However, this does not mean that such data processing activities are entirely unrestricted; on the contrary, in accordance with Article 20 of the Constitution, it mandates that minimum constitutional safeguards be provided by law in these areas as well.
Therefore, particularly in criminal proceedings involving special categories of personal data such as genetic data, it can be argued that the gap arising in areas where the KVKK does not apply must be filled with clear, detailed, and protective regulations at the statutory level.
- THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT’S ASSESSMENT
In its review, the Constitutional Court first emphasized that genetic data, by its very nature, falls among the categories of special-category personal data that must be subject to a high standard of protection. In this context, the Court reiterated that any limitations imposed on the right to the protection of personal data must be regulated by law in a manner that is specific, accessible, and foreseeable.
The Court determined that the contested regulation provides for the immediate destruction of data obtained from genetic testing conducted to gather evidence regarding a crime only in the following cases: the expiration of the appeal period following a decision that there is no basis for prosecution, the rejection of an appeal, or the finalization of a decision of acquittal or a ruling that no penalty is warranted; however, it determined that the regulation permits the continued retention of genetic data in the case file in situations other than those listed above. In this context, the Court concluded that the regulation imposes a limitation on the right to the protection of personal data by permitting, to a certain extent, the retention of genetic testing results obtained during criminal investigations and prosecutions that constitute personal data.
The decision further emphasized that the exclusion of data processing activities within the scope of investigation, prosecution, trial, and enforcement proceedings from the scope of the Law, pursuant to Article 28 of the KVKK, cannot create a legal vacuum regarding personal data obtained during these processes. The Court has established that, since the right to request the protection of personal data is directly guaranteed by Article 20 of the Constitution, it is imperative that such data processing activities falling outside the scope of the KVKK be brought under an independent legal framework consistent with the principles of legality, specificity, and foreseeability.
However, the Court determined that the law does not explicitly regulate fundamental matters such as the retention period and conditions under which genetic data is to be stored—from the issuance of the decisions referred to in Article 80(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code until they become final, as well as in cases other than these decisions, such as conviction, dismissal, or dismissal of the case—how the data subject may exercise their rights of access, rectification, and erasure; the procedures to be followed during the destruction process, and what effective remedies are available regarding these matters. Based on these findings, the Court noted that such deficiencies could lead to a situation inconsistent with the principles of data minimization and storage limitation, exceeding the principle of purpose limitation, and paving the way for indefinite retention; and that this situation demonstrates that the restriction imposed on the right to request the protection of personal data fails to meet the proportionality standard under Article 13 of the Constitution. Accordingly, it was concluded that the rule restricting the right to request the protection of personal data, without providing sufficient safeguards and fundamental principles for the protection of genetic data, does not meet the requirement of legality.
Additionally, the provision in Article 82 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CMK) that the relevant area is to be regulated by a regulation was subject to a separate evaluation; it was concluded that while this matter concerning fundamental rights must be determined by law, leaving a broad regulatory authority with undefined boundaries and scope to the administration is incompatible with the principle of legality.
On these grounds, the Constitutional Court ruled by a majority vote that Article 80, Paragraph 2, and Article 82 of the Criminal Procedure Code (“with respect to Article 80, Paragraph 2”) and ruled by a majority vote that they should be annulled; it further ruled that the annulment provisions shall enter into force nine months after their publication in the Official Gazette.
- CONCLUSION
The Constitutional Court’s decision should be interpreted not merely as the annulment of a provision in the CMK, but as the recognition of a fundamental structural gap in Turkish data protection law regarding judicial data processing activities excluded under Article 28/1-(d) of the KVKK. This structural gap stems from the failure to establish, to date, a comprehensive legal framework—specific to data processing activities carried out by judicial authorities and enforcement bodies acting as data controllers—that is independent of the general provisions of the KVKK yet consistent with them, and that includes regulations on legal basis, purpose limitation, retention periods, destruction obligations, and the rights of data subjects.
In particular, the fact that matters such as the boundaries within which data processing activities are to be conducted, the nature of the retention and destruction regime, and how data subject rights are to be protected—especially regarding judicial activities excluded under Article 28 of the KVKK—have not been addressed through clear and comprehensive legal regulations poses serious risks from the perspective of constitutional oversight.
In this context, regarding personal data processed in judicial and enforcement proceedings: clear and predictable retention periods must be established, data use must be limited to the purpose, effective oversight and appeal mechanisms must be created, and destruction processes must be legally safeguarded.
In this context, the European Union’s 2016/680 “Law Enforcement Directive” (LED) is considered the most functional reference framework for addressing the structural gap in Turkish law. The Directive comprehensively regulates personal data processing activities carried out by competent authorities within the scope of crime prevention, investigation, prosecution, and enforcement activities—independent of the GDPR—along the axes of purpose limitation, data minimization, retention limits, data subject rights, and accountability. Indeed, the goal of full compliance with the GDPR—which is projected to be completed by 2025 according to Turkey’s official policy documents—also encompasses the transposition of this directive into our domestic law. This annulment decision establishes a strong constitutional imperative to accelerate the aforementioned compliance process. It is of great importance that the legislature views the granted nine-month period not merely as a means to fill the gap in the Criminal Procedure Code, but as an opportunity to initiate a systematic legislative effort to comprehensively restructure the judicial data processing regime from a LED perspective.