OUR PUBLICATIONS

CRIME OF CIRCUMVENTING TECHNOLOGICAL MEASURES REGULATED BY THE LAW ON INTELLECTUAL AND ARTISTIC WORKS


14 January 2026 - Av. Esin Esen

CRIME OF CIRCUMVENTING TECHNOLOGICAL MEASURES REGULATED BY THE LAW ON INTELLECTUAL AND ARTISTIC WORKS

The crime of circumventing technological measures is regulated in Article 72 of the Intellectual and Artistic Works Law No. 5846. Accordingly, "For the purpose of protecting the rights set forth in this Law, it is a crime to circumvent effective technological measures provided by protection methods such as access control or encryption, or reproduction control mechanisms, which are implemented to control the use of works, performances, phonograms, productions, and broadcasts in order to ensure the protection of the rights set forth in this Law; a) Those who manufacture or import, distribute, sell, lease, or hold for commercial purposes the products and tools; b) Those who provide advertising, marketing, design, or application services for the products and tools shall be punished with imprisonment from six months to two years."

Acts punished under the crime of circumventing technological measures include various acts related to obtaining, possessing, or disposing of products and tools intended to circumvent technological measures. Therefore, contrary to the title of the article, the material element of this crime does not involve circumventing any measure, but rather the preparatory act is punished. In this case, the crime does not constitute injustice, but it violates the principle of using criminal law as a last resort in the legal system. Actions such as producing software that will render ineffective the software that prevents the copying of a music CD, distributing "crack" software over the internet to enable the unlicensed use of a computer game, or advertising tools or equipment that can be used to access an internet platform without a password or subscription constitute crimes under Article 72 of the FSEK. (Özgüç, 2024).

The crime of circumventing technological measures aims to protect the rights over intellectual and artistic works. These rights are primarily moral and financial rights. However, as stated above, Article 72 of the Copyright Law does not directly address the infringement of these rights. Rather, it penalizes certain actions related to products and tools that could circumvent existing measures protecting these rights. Therefore, unlike Article 71 of the Copyright Law, the accepted understanding under Article 72 of the Copyright Law is that it concerns rights over technological measures themselves, not rights over works protected by technological measures. In this case, it must be accepted that the legal value protected by prohibiting the manufacture of tools or products that circumvent license software preventing reproduction on, for example, a computer program or music CD is not the rights on the computer program or music CD, but the rights on the license software preventing reproduction (Özgüç, 2024). Therefore, the victim of FSEK Art. 72 is ultimately not the person who owns the rights to the protected intellectual and artistic work, but rather the owner of the rights to the protective technological measure on that work. The right to complain also belongs to the owner of the rights to the protective technological measure and the professional association of which he or she is a member (Başlar, 2012).

Although the offense envisaged in Article 72 of the Copyright Law is preparatory in nature to Article 71/1(1) of the Copyright Law, the imposition of a heavier penalty than that envisaged in Article 71 of the Copyright Law is debated in doctrine. This is because it is clear that the negative impact of the preparation of a violation of a legal value on social order is lower than that of a direct violation of this legal value. It is required by Article 13 of the Constitution that the impact of criminal law interventions on fundamental rights and freedoms be proportionate to the severity of the violation created by the act. Similarly, Article 3 of the Turkish Criminal Code also states that the punishment or security measure to be imposed must be proportionate to the severity of the act committed (Özgüç, 2024). 

Finally, it is necessary to focus on the seizure measure in relation to these crimes. Pursuant to Article 75/3 of the FSEK, "Upon complaint, the public prosecutor shall take the necessary steps to seize the items in question as a protective measure in accordance with the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271. The public prosecutor may also, if deemed necessary, decide to suspend the activity limited to the reproduction of the works alleged to have been reproduced unlawfully. However, this decision shall be submitted to the judge for approval within twenty-four hours. A decision not approved by the judge within twenty-four hours shall be void." According to the wording of the law, the prosecutor has no discretion regarding seizure. Products and tools to be seized under FSEK.72 will generally be computer software. In this context, CMK.134 will apply.  Pursuant to CMK.134, "During the seizure of computers or computer files, a backup of all data in the system shall be made... A copy of the backup taken in accordance with the third paragraph shall be given to the suspect or their representative, and this shall be recorded in the minutes and signed." However, the provisions set forth in Articles 72 and 75 of the Copyright Law essentially aim to prevent the unlawful distribution of the relevant software. Providing copies to the suspect or their defense counsel pursuant to CMK.134 creates the possibility of renewed unlawful use. Otherwise, procedural irregularities will arise due to the unlawful acquisition of evidence. It would be beneficial to make the necessary amendments to the law to resolve this contradiction.

Sources

Özgüç, L. E. (2024). Evaluation of the Crime of "Circumventing Technological Measures" in Article 72 of the Intellectual and Artistic Works Law No. 5846. Istanbul Medeniyet University Faculty of Law Criminal Law Symposium Full Text Proceedings, 130-153.

Başlar, Y. (2012). The Crime of Preparatory Acts Aimed at Circumventing Protective Programs. Journal of the Court of Appeals, 1, 243-259.