OUR PUBLICATIONS

DISNEY'S LAWSUIT CONCERNING TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT AND MISLEADING ORIGIN LABELING RELATED TO THE MICKEY MOUSE TRADEMARK


10 September 2025 - Hatice Selin Ağtepe

DISNEY'S LAWSUIT CONCERNING TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT AND MISLEADING ORIGIN LABELING RELATED TO THE MICKEY MOUSE TRADEMARK

AN EXAMINATION OF THE TRANSITION TO PUBLIC DOMAIN STATUS AND THE SCOPE OF COPYRIGHT

In recent years, many important literary and cultural works have entered the public domain in the United States ("US"). The recent inclusion of a version of Mickey Mouse, one of the iconic heroes of our childhood, in this status is undoubtedly one of the most resonant examples. The Walt Disney Company (“Walt Disney”) pioneered the animation industry with its early works and has since grown into a global company operating theme parks, digital platforms, and licensed products. Disney's national and international trademarks related to the creation of "Mickey" and "Mickey Mouse" ("Mickey Mouse Trademarks") have achieved global recognition worldwide as family-oriented, reliable, and appealing to all ages, establishing a unique magic in consumers' minds that they associate with Disney.

Although Walt Disney is widely recognized by the majority of consumers worldwide as synonymous with the Mickey Mouse Brands, this should not be interpreted as meaning that legal disputes have not arisen. Indeed, when a version of the Mickey Mouse Trademarks recently entered the public domain, Red Earth Group Limited ("Red Earth") launched jewelry bearing the "Mickey Mouse" name, citing this status as justification, and this use led to a legal dispute between the parties.

Disney Enterprises Inc. ("Disney"), part of the Walt Disney group and its affiliates[1] , filed a lawsuit against Red Earth in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, Western Division, under case number 2:25-cv-06469, alleging that Red Earth exploited the reputation and trust of consumers in violation of the law and misled consumers for its own commercial gain.

This article will examine Disney's lawsuit against Red Earth for trademark infringement and misleading country of origin labeling; the consequences of Mickey Mouse's transition to public domain status in terms of copyright and trademark law; and the protection periods established in national and international legislation from a comparative perspective.

 

 

  1. Specific Dispute

In the lawsuit filed regarding the commercial use of the Mickey Mouse Trademarks, Disney claimed that its rights to the trademark had been infringed by Red Earth and asserted that it was the sole and exclusive owner of the rights to design, manufacture, market, license, and sell products bearing the Mickey Mouse Trademarks. Within the framework of this exclusive ownership, Disney stated that it only licenses the trademark to authorized sales and distribution companies and that it conducts quality controls on the products of licensees.[2]

Disney claimed that the Mickey jewelry launched by Red Earth infringed upon the Mickey Mouse trademarks and unfairly exploited their reputation. Disney argued that this situation created a misleading perception among consumers that Red Earth was an authorized seller and that the products were original Disney merchandise. It was alleged that consumers had the impression that the products were approved and endorsed by Disney based on the Mickey Mouse Trademarks.

Disney filed a trademark infringement and false origin misrepresentation lawsuit, arguing that when consumers believe the products are licensed by Disney, they evaluate the quality of the products based on this trust, and that this situation damages the brand. It was argued that when consumers believed the products were licensed by Disney, they based their purchasing decisions on this trust, along with the perception that the company's established quality control procedures were also applied to these products.

For this very reason, the measures Disney requested from the court included preventing the defendant and its collaborators from using Mickey Mouse trademarks or similar marks on commercial products, preventing them from aiding trademark infringements, and protecting Disney's brand reputation.

 

 

  1. Mickey Mouse and Copyright

 

The first version of Mickey Mouse (the "First Version") appeared in the 1928 short film Steamboat Willie[3] . The First Version entered the public domain in 2024 due to the 95-year term of copyright protection in the United States ([4] ). [5]Although characters such as Peter Pan, Tinkerbell, Winnie the Pooh, Sherlock Holmes, and Frankenstein have also fallen out of copyright protection, the impact they have had on the public is not comparable to that of Mickey Mouse. The main reason for this is that Mickey has become an integral part of Disney's corporate identity for nearly a century and enjoys widespread recognition in the context of popular culture.

 

In this context, Mickey Mouse's transition to the public domain cannot be considered merely an important development in terms of copyright law; it also has legal and socio-cultural consequences in terms of the preservation of cultural heritage and the accessibility of social knowledge. This means that the copyright protection period has expired and the work in question can now be used without any license or permission request and without paying royalties; new derivative works can be produced based on it. In other words, the restrictions on copyrights on the work have been lifted with the expiration of the 95 (ninety-five) year protection period set by the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act ("CTEA"[6] ) in 2024. Therefore, the First Version of Mickey Mouse has entered the public domain and is now freely available for use by third parties. However, it is important to note that this status is limited to the First Version; subsequent designs and Disney's registered trademarks remain protected.

 

[7]

 

  1. Differences in Protection Periods and National Legislation

 

  1. Term of Protection Under US Law

In the United States, the copyright protection period was set at 50 (fifty) years from the death of the author under the Copyright Act of 1976. However, the CTEA, adopted in 1998, extended this period by 20 (twenty) years, re-establishing it as 70 (seventy) years from the death of the author. The relevant law is also known among the public as the "Mickey Mouse Law."[8] For corporate or "work for hire"[9] works, the term of protection is set at 95 (ninety-five) years from the first publication or 120 (one hundred twenty) years from the creation of the work, whichever expires first. This regulation led to the copyright of the First Version expiring on January 1, 2024, following the completion of the aforementioned periods, and the First Version became public domain.

  1. Term of Protection in Europe and Turkey

Copyrights are valid for the lifetime of the author and for 70 (seventy) years following their death for works such as fine art and literary works. This demonstrates that the protection of the relevant intellectual property rights is not indefinite. For example, in Turkey, works are protected for this period under the Intellectual and Artistic Works Law No. 5846 ("FSEK"). Although the First Version will enter the public domain in the US as of 2024, in Turkey, copyrights for a similar work remain valid for 70 (seventy) years[10] through the creators or heirs of the work. International agreements such as the European Union ("EU") and the Berne Convention stipulate that copyrights shall be protected for at least 50 (fifty) years after the death of the author. Turkey exceeds these standards with a 70 (seventy) year protection period, complying with EU and other international obligations.

  1. Comparison of National Copyright Protection Periods Based on Alan Alexander Milne's ("A.A. Milne") Winnie the Pooh Work

As is well known, copyright laws vary around the world and may change over time. Under UK copyright law, literary and artistic works are protected during the author's lifetime and for 70 (seventy) years after their death. Since A.A. Milne died in 1956, the original Winnie the Pooh stories will enter the public domain in the United Kingdom on January 1, 2027. However, in the United States, where the copyright of a work is protected for 95 (ninety-five) years from the date of its first publication, A.A. Milne's Winnie the Pooh book, published in 1926, entered the public domain in the United States in 2022.  However, the illustrations by E.H. Shepard, which form the visual elements of the work, are subject to separate protection; as Shepard died in 1976, the rights to these drawings will continue until January 1, 2047. Therefore, Winnie the Pooh is still protected in the United Kingdom today; however, this does not automatically apply internationally.[11]

 

  1. Legal Consequences of Public Domain Status

The transition to public domain status, upon the expiration of the protection period stipulated in Article 27 of the Copyright Law, signifies the termination of the financial rights over the work and the work becoming freely available for use. This means that an author, filmmaker, or company is not required to obtain permission to reproduce, create derivative works, or distribute a version of a work that has become public domain.

However, the expiration of the copyright protection period does not mean that all legal protection mechanisms relating to the work cease to exist. In particular, trademark law, including but not limited to names and logos, continues to provide limited protection for works that have entered the public domain. Commercially marketed "merchandise"[12] or "fan art" products may give consumers the impression that they originate from the official rights holder of the brand and may be likely to cause confusion. In this case, such use must also be assessed as trademark infringement or unfair competition.

In this case, the fact that a character has become public domain only grants the right to freely use that version; rights over subsequent versions and registered trademarks remain in force and are protected under copyright and trademark law. At this point, one cannot directly refer to the status of "public domain" without careful examination and evaluation of which versions of the works and characters can be freely used. Therefore, although the First Version has become public domain, subsequent designs following this version, Disney's copyrighted works, and registered trademarks are still protected. In other words, the use of versions other than the First Version, which is in the public domain, that benefit from copyright and trademark protection ( ) will be considered unauthorized use and may lead to trademark infringement and misleading claims of origin.

  1. Evaluation and Conclusion

Copyright is a fundamental intellectual property mechanism that protects creators and their heirs and encourages the production of new works. The expiration of these rights means that the work in question can no longer be privately controlled under intellectual property law. Consequently, a work whose copyright term has expired can no longer be restricted in its use by being owned by a single person or entity. The fundamental principle of copyright is that once a work becomes public domain, it can no longer be used as private property, and even the most creative legal theories cannot invalidate this principle.[13]

Public domain status provides a foundation for future creative activities; it allows creators the freedom to reproduce, publish, distribute, and produce derivative works based on the work in question. Thus, while preserving cultural heritage and promoting access to information, a legal framework is established for the production of new works.

However, the expiration of copyright protection does not mean that all legal protection mechanisms for the work cease to exist. Trademark and unfair competition provisions continue to apply to the work within the framework of relevant legislation. Particularly in terms of trademarks, limited protection is still provided for works that have become public domain.

Unlike copyrights, trademarks do not automatically expire; a trademark can remain valid as long as it is used in commerce and provides legal protection to prevent consumer deception. In this context, the use of a work that has become public domain should not infringe upon the rights of registered trademarks or subsequent versions of the work. Creators must carefully evaluate which versions they can freely use and which elements are still under legal protection. To ensure that consumers correctly understand the source and terms of use of the work, clear and conspicuous warnings, title screens, or covers must clearly indicate the identity of the author of the work.[14]

In order to eliminate the risks arising from trademark law and unfair competition provisions in the commercial use of works that have become public domain, certain concrete measures must be taken in practice. In this context, it is important to conduct a trademark name search and registration record scan to determine whether the terms to be used are compatible with existing trademark registrations. In addition, market place and social media usage scans should be conducted to identify in advance any uses that could potentially cause confusion with third-party trademarks when the work is put into commercial circulation.

Associative checks on product titles, labels, and images will also serve to prevent consumer deception. Pursuant to Article 5 of Industrial Property Law No. 6769, whether the signs are similar to each other is an important criterion in the evaluation of trademark applications. In this context, the similarity between signs is examined as a whole, not just based on a single element, but in terms of their auditory, visual, and semantic aspects. The criterion used in the evaluation is the overall impression left by the signs on the average consumer. Therefore, the similarity of sounds during pronunciation, the visual impact created by the appearance of the signs, or the meanings and connotations expressed by the signs are taken into account together in terms of the possibility of confusion.

As accepted in doctrine and practice, various criteria are taken into account in determining the similarity between signs and the likelihood of confusion. These include whether the goods and services:

  • whether they address a similar customer base,
  • whether they satisfy similar needs,
  • their end users and consumer profiles,
  • whether they can be substituted for one another,
  • whether one can complement the other,
  • opportunities for competition,
  • their intended uses,
  • whether distribution channels are shared, usage methods,
  • the target consumer segment,
  • should be taken into account, and in this way, it should be determined whether the goods and services are similar.[15]

If necessary, license agreements may be concluded to balance the mutual rights and interests of the parties, allowing third parties to use the trademark for a limited period, region, or group of goods and services; or coexistence agreements may be concluded to ensure that the parties can coexist by clearly distinguishing the areas of use or conditions of similar trademarks. Such measures will help prevent potential legal disputes by ensuring a balance between the freedom of use arising from public domain status and the protection afforded by trademark law.

In conclusion, striking the right balance between the freedom afforded by public domain status and the limitations imposed by trademark law not only prevents legal disputes but also ensures the development of creative activities on a secure and sustainable basis.

 

[1] Disney Enterprises, Inc. is a subsidiary of The Walt Disney Company and is the owner of Disney's trademarks and copyrights. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disney_Enterprises (Accessed: 10/05/2025)

[3]

[4] In the US, the Copyright Term Extension Act (Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act), which came into force in 1998, set the copyright protection period at the life of the author +70 years, and 95 years for anonymous/corporate works. See 17 U.S.C. §§ 302–304.

[6] Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act of 1998, Pub. L. No. 105-298, 112 Stat. 2827. For the official text of the law, see U.S. Copyright Office, https://www.copyright.gov/legislation/s505.pdf (Accessed: 05.09.2025)

[7] For the design evolution of the Mickey Mouse character between 1923 and 2023, see https://web.law.duke.edu/cspd/mickey/#_ftn2a (Accessed: 05.09.2025)

[9] If the actual creator of a work is not the person who commissioned the work or the employer, this situation is referred to as 'work for hire'.

[10] FSEK Article 27: The term of protection lasts for the lifetime of the author and for 70 years after their death (Additional sentence: 21/2/2001 - 4630/16 Article). If there is more than one author, this term ends 70 years after the death of the last surviving author.

[12] In retail trade, visual display refers to product design, product selection, packaging, pricing, and the sale of goods that encourage consumers to spend more. See https://tr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merchandising (Accessed: 03.10.2025)

[13] Leslie Klinger v. Conan Doyle Estate, Ltd., No. 14-1128 (7th Cir. 2014) Bkz. https://cases.justia.com/federal/appellate-courts/ca7/14-1128/14-1128-2014-08-04.pdf?ts=1411046549 (Erişim Tarihi: 05.10.2025)

[14] 15 U.S.C. § 1125, False designations of origin, false descriptions, and dilution forbidden (under the U.S. Lanham Act)

[15] Republic of Turkey Ankara 2nd Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights Court, E. 2020/347, K. 2021/155.