Evaluations and Highlights on the Recent Decisions of the KVKK
The Personal Data Protection Board ("Board") published a number of decision summaries on 24.04.2023. The Board's decisions are enlightening regarding controversial and frequently encountered issues in practice, such as the transfer of personal data abroad, the processing of sensitive personal data and camera footage, the obligation of data controllers to disclose information on their websites and the evaluation of the obligation to provide explicit consent within the framework of the provisions of the Personal Data Protection Law ("Law"). In this article, the prominent decisions of the Board will be examined and evaluations regarding these decisions will be made.
- Board Decision No. 2022/107: Electronic Commercial Message
In the case subject to the decision, the data subject complained that the data controller, which is a savings finance company, sent text messages to his/her mobile phone number without his/her express consent or approval.
In data controller's defense, the data controller stated that it is a company registered to the Message Management System ("IYS"), that the phone number record of the data subject is among the records it notified to the IYS system within the scope of the Provisional Article 2 of the Regulation on Commercial Communication and Commercial Electronic Messages (Regulation) issued pursuant to the Law No. 6563 on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce ("Law No. 6563"), and that the data subject has not yet requested SMS rejection at the time of application to the company.
The Board stated that there is a separate legislation regarding commercial electronic messages and that a commercial electronic message should be sent in accordance with the legislation, and stated that the process of sending commercial electronic messages should also be carried out in accordance with the Personal Data Protection Law, since the contact number of the person concerned is a personal data. As a result of the Board's examination of the data controller company and the aforementioned explanations; Board has concluded that the data controller has not taken the necessary technical and administrative measures within the framework of Article 12 of the Law titled "Obligations Regarding Data Security" on the grounds that there is no relationship between the data controller and the data subject that requires registration in the IYS system and that there is no express consent of the data controller for the processing of personal data of the data subject, and decided to impose an administrative fine of 75. 000 TL pursuant to Article 18 of the Law titled "Misdemeanors" and to instruct the data controller to destroy the personal data determined to have been processed unlawfully in accordance with Article 7 of the Law and to inform the Board.[1]
In the Board's decision, the Board prioritized the requirement of seeking express consent in the processing of personal data. In paragraph 1 of Article 5 of the Law titled "Conditions for the processing of personal data", the Board stated that "Personal data cannot be processed without the explicit consent of the data subject" and emphasized the importance of obtaining express consent by imposing administrative fines on data controllers.
- Board's Decision on the Transfer of Image Recordings by the Foreign Exchange Office
In the case subject to the decision, the data subject stated in his complaint that he was overpaid by the counter clerk in the foreign exchange office of the data controller due to a wrong transaction, that he returned the overpaid part after learning about the overpayment, but that the images of him recorded with the security camera in the foreign exchange Office were shared with news agencies and websites without his explicit consent, and that there was no warning sign at the workplace of the data controller that the images were made. The data subject made a written application to the data controller and stated that he/she did not receive a reasonable and sufficient response to the issues in the application petition.
Regarding the complaint of the data subject; data controller stated that it answered the written application of the data subject in detail together with the photographs showing the camera records of the incident, that the data subject went to the foreign exchange office and wanted to exchange money in foreign currency, but the money machine was mistaken when determining the amount of money due to the crumpled condition of the money brought, that the teller did not pay attention to this situation and gave the money specified on the screen to the data subject, that the teller was responsible for the erroneous transaction and that the cash deficit was written to the teller's account and recorded in his/her registry, The data subject did not return the overpaid money to the data controller even after a reasonable period of time, one day after the incident occurred, an internationally broadcasting television channel came to the foreign exchange office for shooting, there is a possibility that the erroneous transaction made due to the non-return of the money within a reasonable period of time was made deliberately by the data subject and he wanted to solve this problem before the matter was referred to the prosecutor's office, since they did not have the name, address, telephone number, etc. with which the data controller could contact the person concerned, only the person concerned could recognize himself, and that the data controller gave the channel images of the person concerned in which only the area around his eyes could be seen.
Regarding the complaint of the data subject that "the data controller did not fulfill its obligation to inform", the Board stated in Article 26 of the Communiqué (Communiqué No: 2018-32/45) that "Authorized establishments are obliged to have a sufficient number of cameras or video recording systems installed in a working manner to show each teller, cash machine and persons performing transactions. ", and that the processing of the personal data of the data subject through camera recording is based on the condition that "it is mandatory for the data controller to fulfill its legal obligation" specified in paragraph 2 of Article 5 of the Law.
Regarding the allegations that the data subject was not enlightened about the fact that camera recordings were made, the Board evaluated that the data subject was enlightened about the fact that camera recordings were made because he saw that the signs "This workplace is monitored by cameras 24/7 for your safety" were hung in different places of the exchange office.
As a result of the Board's examination of the data controller foreign exchange office and the aforementioned explanations; since it is a legal obligation to have a camera in the foreign exchange office, the processing of the images of the person concerned by making camera and video recordings was carried out based on the processing condition of fulfilling the legal obligation of the data controller within the scope of Article 5, Article 2, subparagraph (ç) of the Law. Regarding the allegations that the person was not informed that the camera recording was made, it has come to the conclusion that the condition of informing the relevant persons about the camera recording has been met due to the fact that the signs "This workplace is monitored by camera 24/7 for your safety" are hung in various parts of the foreign exchange office, and has decided that there is no action to be taken within the scope of the Law regarding the complaint of the person concerned. [2]
In order to ensure the return of the overpayment made by the data controller to the data subject, the data controller has decided that the provision of the camera recording images showing the eye area of the data subject to the local news channel for the purpose of the announcement is a transaction to be made within the scope of the Law, as it meets the processing condition of "It is mandatory to process data for the legitimate interests of the data controller, provided that it does not harm the fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject" according to subparagraph f of paragraph 2 of Article 5 of the Law.
In the concrete case, the Board made an assessment as to whether the data processing is mandatory or not by comparing the interests of the data controller with the transfer of the video recordings of the data subject to third parties. The Board concluded that the data controller's giving the images of the data subject to the TV channel in such a way that he/she can recognize himself/herself provides a benefit that is competitive with the transfer of the camera recording images to the local news channel for the purpose of the announcement. In the Board's assessment, the Board took into account the following points: that no personal data such as the name and surname of the data subject are available, since no transactions are made with the names and surnames of the customers during the foreign currency exchange transaction; that the only way to ensure the return of the overpayment is to provide the TV channel with the video recordings of the data subject; and that if the announcement is not made, the missing amount of money will be collected from the teller and will be registered in the teller's record.
C. Board's Decision on Transfer of Personal Data Abroad without Express Consent
A complaint was filed against the data controller by the data subject due to the fact that he/she became a member of the data controller's system via the website, that there is no cookie policy on the website, that it is reported in the clarification text that the data is transferred abroad, but the data subject does not have an express consent in this regard, that he/she applied to the e-mail address in the clarification text on the website, but no response was received from the data controller within the legal period despite requesting information about which data was recorded and transferred.
In its defense, the data controller stated that the application sent to the e-mail address of the data subject could not be responded due to the fact that it was not noticed, that it provides services in seven countries outside Turkey, that it provides its services with cloud service technologies located abroad, that the notification of transfer abroad in the disclosure text on the website was made because the data was kept on this server, that many technology companies with operations in Turkey also receive services from the company they work with due to the insufficient hosting services offered in Turkey, that they are working on a commitment letter with the company from which they receive hosting services within the scope of Article 9 of the Law and that they will submit the commitment letter to the Board for approval as soon as possible.
As a result of the Board's examination of the data controller company and the aforementioned explanations; since it was determined that the data controller transferred the personal data abroad by using the system whose servers are located abroad, that a letter of undertaking regarding the adequate protection to be provided in the country of transfer was not submitted to the Board before the transfer of personal data, that only explicit consent was stated as a legal reason for the transfer activity abroad, in this respect, it was determined that the data controller transferred the personal data abroad without obtaining explicit consent from the data subject, it was concluded that the necessary technical and administrative measures were not taken to ensure the appropriate level of security in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 12 of the Law. Since it is concluded that the necessary technical and administrative measures to ensure the appropriate level of security have not been taken, the data controller operates in many countries, its economic situation, unlawfully transfers the personal data of a large number of users abroad through the application and website used in the processing of personal data, and a large number of data subjects are affected by this act. It has been concluded that it is admitted in the defense petition that the activity of transferring personal data has been carried out systematically, deliberately and with executive action by the data controller and that the transfer of personal data abroad has not been made in accordance with the regulations in the Law despite the 6 years that have passed since the date of entry into force of the Law and pursuant to Article 18 of the Law titled “Misdemeanor”, it has decided to instruct the data controller to impose an administrative fine of 950.000 TL and to make necessary arrangements to make the transactions regarding the transfer of personal data abroad comply with Article 9 of the Law and to inform the Board about the result. [3] The data controller has been warned to take all necessary administrative and technical measures to finalize the applications to be made by the relevant persons within the scope of the Communiqué on the Procedures and Principles of Application to the Data Controller effectively, in accordance with the law and the rule of honesty.
The Board imposed administrative fines on the data controller in order to ensure compliance with the legislation regarding the transfer of personal data abroad. Pursuant to Article 9 of the Law, personal data may be transferred abroad without seeking explicit consent if there is adequate protection regarding the confidentiality and security of the data subjects in foreign countries to which personal data is transferred. However, since the list of safe countries has not yet been announced by the Board, in the activity of transferring personal data abroad, explicit consent must be obtained from the data subject or a letter of undertaking must be submitted to the Board by the data controller that adequate protection will be provided in the country before the said activity is carried out, and the Board must authorize the transfer. In the case subject to the complaint, the data controller informed the data subject about the transfer of personal data abroad in the disclosure text on its website, but the freely given explicit consent of the data subject was not obtained. Since the data controller did not have a letter of undertaking application approved by the Board, explicit consent must be obtained from the data subject according to the legal regulations, but the data controller did not fulfill the explicit consent requirement.
D. Board's Decision Not to Provide Clarification and Explicit Consent Texts Regarding Cookies on the Website
In the case subject to the decision, the data subject stated in his complaint that the users were not informed about the cookie processing processes when logging in to the website of a gaming platform, that explicit consent was not obtained for non-mandatory cookies, that identity and contact information was requested from the users who registered to the site, but that clarification and explicit consent texts were not provided, and that although he applied to the data controller company, he did not receive an adequate response.
In response to the complaint of the data subject it was stated that; the website belongs to them but another company is responsible for its operations in Turkey, that the disclosure text can be accessed through the link shared on the site and that the purpose of processing personal data is explained comprehensively in this text, that there is a telephone and identity confirmation requirement for sellers on the site, which is a prerequisite for making sales. The data controller has stated that this information is entered into the site with the acceptance of the sellers and that the information received is requested only due to the legal liability arising from the commission agreement formed during the sale, and that the processing of this data is essential for the data controller against possible legal liability due to the liability arising from the commission agreement on the site and the right of recourse arising from the damages that the buyer may suffer after the sale.
As a result of the Board's examination of the data controller company and the aforementioned explanations; the Board has determined that the data controller processes personal data without any processing conditions on the website through non-mandatory cookies such as advertising and marketing purposes, and since this situation constitutes a violation of the obligations set out in Article 12 of the Law, an administrative fine of 300,000 TL will be imposed on the data controller in accordance with Article 18 of the Law titled "Misdemeanors", and an administrative fine of 300,000 TL will be imposed on the data controller in accordance with Article 10 of the Law and the provisions of the Communiqué on the Procedures and Principles to be Followed in Fulfilling the Disclosure Obligation regarding the personal data processed with cookies on the website and to inform the Board about the result. It was further decided to instruct the data controller to inform the Board about the result by arranging the deficiencies detected in the disclosure text in accordance with Article 10 of the Law and the relevant provisions of the Communiqué, although it is understood that the disclosure text regarding the personal data processed during the filling of the registration form submitted to the users. [4]
In the Board's decision, the Board evaluated whether the condition of obtaining express consent from the data subject is fulfilled by classifying cookies according to the purpose they serve and the sources from which they are formed. Express consent was not obtained from the data subject for non-mandatory cookies. It has been identified by the Board that the data controller processes personal data without any processing conditions on the website through non-mandatory cookies such as advertising and marketing purposes. Advertisers, who collect or purchase a lot of data, including personal data, especially through cookies, focus on the behavior of the target audience and present advertisements that will attract their attention. [5]
E. Board's Decision on Processing of Sensitive Personal Data without Express Consent
In the complaint made by the data subject, in summary; the data controller, who is the operator of a gym, processes the health data (fat, weight, blood type, etc.) and biometric data (fingerprints taken at the entrance to the gym) and camera images of the people who receive services from the gym, but that no disclosure was made within the scope of the law regarding this data and that the explicit consent of the persons was not obtained, that the e-mail containing the questions of the person concerned was not answered by the data controller within the legal period, that the cards containing the personal data of the persons concerned can be accessed by anyone working in the gym and that the security of the information is not ensured due to the loss of the cards from time to time, and that the gym officials monitor the camera recordings.
In the defense made by the data controller, it stated that the data subject's personal data other than the personal data in the membership agreement signed by the data subject to receive services were not processed, that the data subject gave his/her signed consent as "I have read, understood and approved" to the section "I want SMS marketing activities" in the membership agreement and thus accepted the processing of personal data, that the data such as height and weight of the gym members are not received unless they request it and that this issue is also stated in the contract, and that there is no data entry of this nature belonging to the data subject in the concrete case.
As a result of the Board's examination of the data controller gym operator and the aforementioned explanations; blood group, which is a special category of personal data, was processed by the data controller for gym membership, but the explicit consent of the data subject was not obtained in this data processing activity, the personal data of many members were processed within the scope of the membership contract of the gym operated by the data controller, the processing of special categories of personal data brings certain risks, the data controller did not respond to the application of the data subject, and considering that the data controller operates in other sectors besides gym management, the Board has decided to 100. 000 TL administrative fine pursuant to Article 18 of the Law titled "Misdemeanors", that the texts of clarification and explicit consent should not be included in the contract text presented to the members but should be organized separately, that the explicit consent should be presented to the data subjects in a way to include the options of giving and withholding consent for each activity, that the clarification text should be organized in accordance with the relevant provisions of Article 10 of the Law as well as the Communiqué on the Procedures and Principles to be Followed in Fulfillment of the Disclosure Obligation and that the data controller should be instructed to inform the Board about the transactions made, and that the data controller should be instructed to inform the Board about the transactions made, pursuant to Article 11 of the Law. it was decided to remind the data controller to show the necessary sensitivity to respond appropriately to the applications of the data subjects received from now on, and it was decided that there was no data breach within the scope of the available information and data regarding the complaint that the security of the data contained in the information cards of the data subjects and the visual records processed with security cameras was not ensured and that there is no action to be taken in this regard. [6]
REFERENCES
1. https://kvkk.gov.tr/Icerik/7557/2022-107
2. https://kvkk.gov.tr/Icerik/7586/2022-1249
3. https://kvkk.gov.tr/Icerik/7558/2022-249
4. https://kvkk.gov.tr/Icerik/7595/2022-1358
5.Çolak,B. ve Tevetoğlu,M.(2021).Dijital Reklamcılığın Yol Açtığı Hukuki Sorunlar ve Çözüm Önerileri.Maltepe Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakütlesi Dergisi,(1),43-86.
6. https://kvkk.gov.tr/Icerik/7594/2022-1357
7. https://kvkk.gov.tr/Icerik/6913/2020-404