Judicial Review of Sanctions Imposed by the Personal Data Protection Board in the Context of Interference with Fundamental Rights
The decision of the Constitutional Court published in the Official Gazette dated 15.12.2023[1] draws attention in terms of examining the effects of administrative fines imposed by the Personal Data Protection Board ("Board") within the framework of Law No. 6698 on Personal Data Protection ("Law No. 6698" or "PDPL") on the property right protected by Article 35 of the Constitution and the judicial reviews of these fines conducted by Criminal Courts of Peace.
Therefore, this study is presented to inform you about the mentioned Constitutional Court decision.
I. Pre-process of Individual Application
The Applicant (Applicant Company), who applied to the Constitutional Court with an individual application claiming an unjust interference with the right to property as a result of the administrative fine imposed by the Board and the subsequent judicial review, is a holding company based abroad, operating hotels in different countries, and providing franchise services.
The Applicant Company, which acquired another accommodation company (Acquired Company) on 8/9/2016, received a warning about a data breach on the date of the acquisition. On 19/11/2018, it was confirmed that an unauthorized third party had accessed the guest reservation database of the Acquired Company. Within 11 days, the Applicant Company issued a press release, provided advice on how data subjects could protect themselves, and sent emails to those affected with valid email addresses.
Subsequently, on 3/12/2018, the Applicant Company notified the Personal Data Protection Authority of the data breach. In this notification, it summarized that:
- 500 million customer records were copied due to the data breach,
- Unauthorized access to the data network occurred as of July 2014, and the detection date of unauthorized access was 8/9/2018,
- Approximately 327 million customers' personal data was stolen,
- The data affected by the breach are not sensitive personal data.
Based on this notification, the Board conducted an investigation and determined that a data breach had occurred. As a result, the Board has ordered the Applicant Company to provide them with the number of customers affected in Turkey and their plans to handle the situation.
The Applicant stated that they had approximately 383 million customer records, 1.24 million of which indicated Turkey as the address. However, they emphasized that this did not mean there were as many customers as the stated quantities or that all these customers were Turkish. It was also mentioned that multiple records were frequently opened for the same customer. Additionally, it was pointed out that the title of data controller belonged to the Acquired Company and not the Applicant.
By 16/5/2019, the Board decided to impose a total administrative fine of 1,450,000 TL on the Applicant Company. The justification was the failure to take necessary technical and administrative measures to ensure data security and the failure to report the breach promptly.
After the Board's decision, the Applicant Company applied to Istanbul Anatolian Criminal Courts of Peace No. 1 (Court) for the annulment of the decision. Following the rejection of the objection due to lack of jurisdiction, the Court re-examined the objection, and based on general expressions, ruled against the objection to the administrative sanction decision. Subsequently, the Applicant Company appealed the decision to the Criminal Courts of Peace No. 2 but did not achieve the desired outcome.
Therefore, the Applicant Company appealed to the Constitutional Court, claiming that the administrative fines imposed by the Board constituted a violation of the right to property.
II. Legislation Considered in the Decision
The main legislation to be examined is Law No. 6698 and its relevant articles. As the basis for the administrative sanction, the Board referred to Article 12/1 (b) of Law No. 6698, which states the failure to take sufficient measures for the security of the data network and the violation of the obligation to report the breach promptly as grounds for administrative fines.
In addition to the relevant articles of Law No. 6698, the Constitutional Court referred to Article 34 of the Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271, emphasizing the obligation of judges and courts to provide reasoned decisions.
Regarding the procedures and principles of personal data breach notifications, the relevant part of the Personal Data Protection Board's decision dated 24/1/2019 and numbered 2019/10 explicitly states that the expression "notification to the Board as soon as a data breach is detected" in Article 12 of Law No. 6698 should be interpreted as 72 hours from the date of learning about the breach and those notifications to the data subjects should be made within a reasonable time after identifying their identities.
In addition to local legislation, it is essential to recall some sources in international law. According to Article 7 of the Council of Europe Convention for the Protection of Individuals with regard to Automatic Processing of Personal Data, appropriate security measures must be taken to prevent the accidental or unauthorized acquisition and disclosure of automatically recorded personal data. Similarly, Article 32 of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) of the European Union states that the controller and processor, taking into account the risks, must implement appropriate technical and organizational measures to ensure a level of security appropriate to the risks.
The most fundamental measure is the encryption method; measures such as limiting the number of password entry attempts to protect against common attacks like brute force algorithms (BFA) are recommended.[2] Article 33 of the General Data Protection Regulation of the European Union, similar to Article 12/5 of Law No. 6698, regulates the obligation to notify, but the difference is that this article specifies a clear period of 72 hours from the date of learning about the data breach for the fulfillment of the obligation.
In this application concerning the alleged violation of the right to property, it is essential to mention Article 35 of the Constitution. Our Constitution recognizes the right to property as one of the fundamental rights and freedoms, and it is emphasized that this right can only be restricted for public interest purposes and by law, in accordance with Article 13 of the Constitution, which regulates the limitation of fundamental rights and freedoms. Therefore, for any intervention in the right to property to be lawful, it must be based on law, serve a public interest purpose, and be proportionate.
III. Points Emphasized by the Constitutional Court
The Constitutional Court determined that the essence of the complaint made by the applicant was the violation of the right to property due to the imposition of an administrative fine, and it emphasized that the right to property is not an unlimited fundamental right. However, it was stated that, according to Article 13 of the Constitution, this right can be limited only if the principles of legality, legitimate aim, and proportionality are present together.
When evaluating the legality and legitimacy conditions during the assessment of the lawfulness of the intervention, it was observed that the legality principle is provided within the scope of Article 12 of Law No. 6698, first and fifth paragraphs, and the legitimacy principle is fulfilled due to the nature of the obligations imposed on data controllers and the sanctions applied in case of a breach, aiming to protect the public interest. In the assessment of the proportionality principle, the sub-principle of proportionality was examined, emphasizing the necessity of establishing a fair balance between the purpose and the means.
During the proportionality examination conducted by the Constitutional Court, noteworthy findings were made. The first of these findings is the distinction between the protection of personal data and the protection of data security. Accordingly, the primary purpose of data security is to ensure the protection of personal data lawfully processed and stored against the risks of accidental and/or unauthorized access, alteration, or disclosure by third parties. In essence, the protection of personal data refers to the legal limits set for the protection of fundamental rights and freedoms during the processing of this data, while the protection of data security refers to the technical and administrative measures to be taken directly to protect the data itself.
Within the framework of Law No. 6698, when determining the appropriate security level for the protection of personal data and ensuring data security, the size or financial balance of the company is essential, and the nature of the personal data being protected is equally important. Also, according to Law No. 6698, if the data controller processes personal data on behalf of another natural or legal person, the data controller is jointly responsible with these persons within the scope of Article 12 of this law.
In addition, it is accepted that the administration has discretionary power in imposing administrative fines and applying proportionate sanctions to ensure the appropriate security level for data security. Therefore, the imposition of administrative fines by the Board in case of a violation of the obligation to ensure the appropriate security level for data security under Law No. 6698 is considered a suitable tool.
However, the Applicant Company's claims raised in the appeal to the Criminal Courts of Peace, such as the lack of sufficient justification in the administrative fine decision by the Board, the inapplicability of the administrative fine in terms of time considering the breach date and the effective date of the Law, the Applicant Company not being the party responsible for the breach due to the fact that the data breach occurred in the Acquired Company, the prompt fulfillment of the notification obligation shortly after the detection of the breach, the interpretation of the uncertainty in the time specified in Article 12/5 of the Law against them, the post hoc issuance of the Board's decision 2019/10 after the breach, and the argument that the principles of fault liability should be applied within the scope of Law No. 6698, and the unlawfulness of imposing a penalty at the highest limit despite taking all precautions and having no fault, were not addressed in the reasoning of the decision issued by the Criminal Courts of Peace. Effective examination by a court of individuals' claims of unlawfulness is crucial in determining the legality of interference with the claimed right (in our specific case, the right to property).
IV. Decision Regarding the Violation of the Right to Property
The Constitutional Court emphasized that the effective examination by relevant courts of allegations of unlawfulness raised during the exercise of the right to object is essential for the proportionality assessment of the interference with the fundamental right in question, such as the right to property.
Furthermore, the Constitutional Court evaluated the failure of the Criminal Courts of Peace to make any assessment on the objections raised by the Applicant during the exercise of the right to object, and this, rightly so, was considered by the Constitutional Court as a violation of the right to property.
In conclusion, the Constitutional Court stated that the exercise of the right to object during the objection process, where allegations of unlawfulness were raised, is crucial for the effective protection of fundamental rights. The failure of the Criminal Courts of Peace to evaluate these objections led to a violation of the right to property.
[1] Application No: 2020/7518, Decision Date: 12.10.2023
[2] Personal Data Protection Authority, PERSONAL DATA SECURITY GUIDE (Technical and Administrative Measures), pgs. 17, 2018.