Legal Sources of Information Systems Security Regulations in Financial Markets and Their Assessment for Crypto Asset Service Providers
Regulations related to information security in financial markets aim to ensure that institutions operating in these markets protect customer data, take precautions against cyber-attacks, and minimize information security breaches. Examples of such regulations include the recent adoption of "secure search" by banks and the widely recognized "multi-factor authentication" systems. Additionally, along with precautions taken at the interface level, measures to secure the database to protect user data can also be added to this list.
This article discusses the legal foundations of the measures implemented by banks and other relevant institutions to protect information systems security in digital banking, open banking, service model banking systems, and the potential application of these regulations to crypto asset service providers that have become capital market institutions under relevant legislation.
1. **Definition and Scope**
Before examining the legal foundations of information security regulations in financial markets, it is beneficial to clarify what is meant by these concepts. Information systems refer to the "human resources, operational activities and processes related to the collection, processing, storage, distribution, and use of information, as well as the information technologies interacting with them." Financial market players responsible for ensuring the security of these information systems can be defined as follows:
- **Open Banking:** A service model where individual and corporate customers share their financial data with other banks and institutions with their consent, enabling them to monitor all their accounts from a single place.
- **Digital Banking:** A banking channel where banking needs are met without the need to visit a branch, through a phone or the internet.
- **Service Model Banking:** A system where banks offer their products and services for use by non-bank companies.
To ensure the secure provision of banking, open banking, digital banking, and service model banking systems, service providers are required to meet due care and diligence obligations. These obligations are also regulated for other institutions operating in capital markets.
These obligations primarily find their sources in secondary regulations prepared by the Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency (“BRSA”) under Article 93 of the Banking Law No. 5411 and in secondary regulations prepared by the Capital Markets Board (“CMB”) under Article 128 of the Capital Markets Law No. 6362.
2. **Regulation on Banks’ Information Systems and Electronic Banking Services**
The Regulation on Banks’ Information Systems and Electronic Banking Services (“BS-EB Regulation”) is the main source of these regulations for banks. It is designed to ensure that banks establish a secure and effective structure for their information systems and electronic banking services, protect customer data, and act in accordance with legal regulations.
The BS-EB Regulation mandates that banks conduct audits to ensure compliance with legal regulations in their information systems applications and report the results of these audits to relevant authorities. Defining the scope of due diligence obligations is crucial for determining the extent of banks' responsibilities. The Supreme Court has held banks liable in cases where the information systems risk management process was not conducted properly, and processes were not closely monitored and audited.
Examples of the regulations in the BS-EB Regulation include:
- **Information Systems Governance** (Section 1) and **Information Security Organization, Roles, and Responsibilities** (Article 8) regarding management roles and responsibilities.
- **Management of Information Systems Risks** (Section 2) detailing the risk management process.
- **Data Privacy** (Article 9) and **Network Security** (Article 14) regarding the protection of data and network security in banking operations.
- **Creation and Monitoring of Log Records** (Article 13) regarding the establishment of a log record mechanism.
- **Management of External Service Procurement** (Article 29) detailing the scope and critical aspects of services to be procured externally.
- **Internal Control and Internal Audit Activities of Information Systems** (Section 7) regarding the determination of internal policies, procedures, and standards.
- **Identity Authentication and Transaction Security** (Article 34) detailing multi-factor authentication procedures.
Additionally, banks are required to keep their primary and secondary systems within the country, as mandated by Article 25. The regulation also extends these obligations to cloud systems and external services, ensuring that any information systems and their backups used in the execution of activities are kept within the country.
3. **Regulation on the Operation Principles of Digital Banks and Service Model Banking**
The Regulation on the Operation Principles of Digital Banks and Service Model Banking (“Digital Banks and Service Model Banking Regulation”) sets forth the requirements for the establishment, application processes, and operational permits of digital banks, as well as the corporate governance structures, risk management, internal control mechanisms, and information security policies they must adhere to.
Article 12 of the Digital Banks and Service Model Banking Regulation requires that the information systems of these institutions be assessed for adequacy as a condition for operational permits. Compliance with regulatory and audit processes, as well as the necessity for regular audits and improvements based on audit findings, is also stipulated in this regulation.
Furthermore, the regulation governs the relationships between digital banks and external service providers within the framework of service model banking, ensuring these providers comply with information security standards.
According to Article 13(5) of the Digital Banks and Service Model Banking Regulation, service banks and interface providers are jointly responsible for ensuring that the interface providers comply with the multi-factor authentication and transaction security obligations mentioned in the third section of the BS-EB Regulation.
4. **Information Systems Management Communiqué (VII-128.9) and Information Systems Independent Audit Communiqué (III-62.2)**
The "Information Systems Management Communiqué" and the "Information Systems Independent Audit Communiqué" issued under the Capital Markets Law No. 6362 outline the management and audit principles for the information systems of capital market institutions listed in the second article of the communiqué. These regulations aim to assess the information systems and associated risks of capital market actors, defining criteria for compliance, effectiveness, and adequacy.
However, certain institutions are exempt from the independent audit of information systems under the Capital Markets Law. These institutions are listed in Article 28 of the Information Systems Management Communiqué (VII-128.9).
Article 2(2) of the Information Systems Management Communiqué (VII-128.9) states that the information systems of banks, insurance companies, leasing companies, factoring companies, and finance companies will be audited under their specific regulations. Article 2(1) lists the institutions and organizations required to comply with the provisions of the Information Systems Management Communiqué (VII-128.9), including:
- Borsa Istanbul A.Ş.,
- Exchanges and market operators and other organized market places,
- Pension investment funds,
- Istanbul Settlement and Custody Bank Inc.,
- Central Registry Agency Inc.,
- Custodian institutions,
- Capital Markets Licensing Registry and Training Agency Inc.,
- Capital market institutions,
- Publicly traded companies,
- The Association of Capital Market Institutions of Turkey,
- The Association of Appraisal Experts of Turkey.
The Information Systems Management Communiqué (VII-128.9) imposes similar obligations as the BS-EB Regulation, such as:
- **Management of Information Systems** (Section 2) and **Senior Management Oversight and Responsibility** (Article 7) regarding the roles and responsibilities of management.
- **Information Systems Risk Management** (Article 8) detailing the risk management process.
- **Data Privacy** (Article 17) and **Network Security** (Article 13) regarding the protection of data and network security in banking operations.
- **Creation of a Record Mechanism** (Article 22) regarding the establishment of a record mechanism.
- **Management of External Services Related to Information Systems** (Article 18) detailing the scope and critical aspects of services to be procured externally.
- **Establishment and Management of Information Systems Controls** (Article 9) regarding the determination of internal policies, procedures, and standards.
- **Identity Authentication** (Article 14) regarding password policies.
Additionally, Article 26 of the Information Systems Management Communiqué (VII-128.9) mandates that institutions and organizations keep their primary and secondary systems within the country.
5. **Conclusion Regarding Crypto Asset Service Providers**
It could be argued that the communiqués mentioned above, issued under the Capital Markets Law No. 6362, could apply to crypto asset service providers that have become capital market institutions under Article 2(1)(g) of the Information Systems Management Communiqué (VII-128.9).
However, recent amendments to the Capital Markets Law include Article 99/B(2), stating that "The financial audit and information systems independent audit of crypto asset service providers shall be conducted by independent audit firms listed by the Board. Additional procedures and principles regarding the information systems audit shall be determined by the Board after consulting with TÜBİTAK or other relevant institutions and organizations as deemed necessary. Board personnel and other personnel assigned under the first paragraph of this article may participate in the audits conducted by the authorized organizations as observers, without compromising the principle of auditor independence. Those participating in this manner shall not bear any responsibility for the audit results reached by the independent audit firms and cannot use the knowledge gained for personal benefit or to benefit another authorized organization."
The recent notice published by the CMB on July 2, 2024, requires documents related to the information systems infrastructure used by companies, the protection of customer assets, the processes related to recording transactions on the blockchain, integrations with other internal and external systems, and operational and reporting processes. This pre-audit mechanism also lays the foundation for routine information security audits. It appears that the measures designed to ensure information security for banking and capital markets institutions can also be followed here.
Additionally, Article 99/A added to the Capital Markets Law aims to narrow the scope of unauthorized crypto asset service providers by stipulating that activities conducted